ok heres what i think is our current top 10 players at Collingwood at the moment. These are exclusively my views and do ot represent those of the match committee..........lol
1 Bloody Obvious - Nathan Buckley
2 Chris Tarrant - Brilliant and super quick
3 Shane Obree - Very underrated and plays well week in week out
4 Tarkyn Lockyer - Most improved player and exceptional kick
5 Josh Fraser - Will improve more as he continues to build up
6 Nick Davis - Very vital cog in the team and great kick
7 Scott Burns would be higher but had a few injury problems. Big Heart
8 Jarrod Molloy - Physical presence is great in our forward line
9 Glenn Freeborn - Very very underated but performs every week very rarely gets beaten
10 Anthony Rocca - Still hasd plenty of Improvement left in him
No doubt people will disagree but its just a matter of opinion and everyone is entitled to one. Freeborn will surprise many people but i believe he does his job week in and week out and uses the ball efficiently.
EVERYONE IS A COLLINGWOOD SUPPORTER ITS JUST THAT SOME PEOPLE ARE IN DENIAL
Top Ten players at Magpie land
Moderator: bbmods
-
magpie24
- Posts: 311
- Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2000 6:01 pm
- Location: Hurstbridge Melb Vic
- Contact:
My top 10
1 Bucks-no comment
2 obree- always in having a go
3 Tarrant-future superstar
4 Tarkyn-I am not biased but this bloke is pure heart...........
5 Richardson- gotta hand it to Richo proved alot of people wrong including me.
6 Nick Davis-He is a big part of the future
7 Josh Fraser-If we can get someone to do the ruck this boy will be the best CHF ever seen???
8 Shane Wakelin- keeping a opposition forward quiet every week.
9 Jarrod Malloy- his physical presence is huge.
10 Carl Stienfort-he has meant so much to the side taking an opposition player out.
When you have a good look at it you could pick em all GO PIES
WE WILL RISE IN OUR OWN WAY
1 Bucks-no comment
2 obree- always in having a go
3 Tarrant-future superstar
4 Tarkyn-I am not biased but this bloke is pure heart...........
5 Richardson- gotta hand it to Richo proved alot of people wrong including me.
6 Nick Davis-He is a big part of the future
7 Josh Fraser-If we can get someone to do the ruck this boy will be the best CHF ever seen???
8 Shane Wakelin- keeping a opposition forward quiet every week.
9 Jarrod Malloy- his physical presence is huge.
10 Carl Stienfort-he has meant so much to the side taking an opposition player out.
When you have a good look at it you could pick em all GO PIES
WE WILL RISE IN OUR OWN WAY
-
MagpieBoy
- Posts: 109
- Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2001 6:01 pm
- Location: Melboune , Victoria , Australia
My Top 10 Players:
1. N.Buckley - Because He Has Stayed At The Club When We Have Been Through Our Ups And Downs.
2. S.O'Bree - Good Player To Watch, Makes Me Get Up And Scream " Come On O'Bree RUN"
3. C.Tarrant - Love His Style Of Player and Give him 1 more year and will kick 100 goals.
4. T.Lockyer - Most Improved Player Over , Because Of Micky, give him a chance.
5. S.Wakelin - Always Proforms Well Against His Player And Keeps them to a low level.
6. J.Fraser - Always trys his best, and his still young, and still learning.
7. J.Molloy - Always Cleans Up A Player,(did micky give him instructions to that) and better than Mal Michaels.
8. N.Davis - Good running player, set up plays well.
9. G.Freeborn - Always beats his Player, and puts in heart every week.
10. C.Stienfort - Plays Well, Goes In Hard and Plays With Heart!
We Are Black
We Are White
We Are The Black AND white Army
Go Pies!!
1. N.Buckley - Because He Has Stayed At The Club When We Have Been Through Our Ups And Downs.
2. S.O'Bree - Good Player To Watch, Makes Me Get Up And Scream " Come On O'Bree RUN"
3. C.Tarrant - Love His Style Of Player and Give him 1 more year and will kick 100 goals.
4. T.Lockyer - Most Improved Player Over , Because Of Micky, give him a chance.
5. S.Wakelin - Always Proforms Well Against His Player And Keeps them to a low level.
6. J.Fraser - Always trys his best, and his still young, and still learning.
7. J.Molloy - Always Cleans Up A Player,(did micky give him instructions to that) and better than Mal Michaels.
8. N.Davis - Good running player, set up plays well.
9. G.Freeborn - Always beats his Player, and puts in heart every week.
10. C.Stienfort - Plays Well, Goes In Hard and Plays With Heart!
We Are Black
We Are White
We Are The Black AND white Army
Go Pies!!
-
magpie jeff
BUCKS
TARRANT
FRASER
OBREE
RINTOUL
MALLOY
LOCKYER
WAKELIN
BURNS
STEINFORT
There is nothing in life greater, than to be a supporter of our beloved collingwood football club,we must remain united,we must stand tall,we must be prepared to fight for our glorious black and white for we are the ENVY OF ALL NATIONS.'YOU'LL NEVER WALK ALONE'
http://www.mp3.com/joffa
TARRANT
FRASER
OBREE
RINTOUL
MALLOY
LOCKYER
WAKELIN
BURNS
STEINFORT
There is nothing in life greater, than to be a supporter of our beloved collingwood football club,we must remain united,we must stand tall,we must be prepared to fight for our glorious black and white for we are the ENVY OF ALL NATIONS.'YOU'LL NEVER WALK ALONE'
http://www.mp3.com/joffa
-
Fradam
- Posts: 1487
- Joined: Mon Jun 21, 1999 6:01 pm
- Location: Bendigo, Victoria
ok I tried to pick a top ten but then i had to leave out names that i wanted to put in even though the deserved a mention so my solution was to do a top 38. let me tell you that my list is biased, i play favourites!!!!!!!. I know saying my list is right but you don't have to worry since I'm not coach.
1. Tarrant
2. Buckley
3. N Davis
4. Fraser
5. Adkins
6. Burns
7. Rocca
8. Richardson
9. Lockyer
10. Lonie
11. Prestigiacomo
12. Didak
13. Wakelin
14. Betheras
15. Steinfort
16. O'Bree
17. Holland
18. Clement
19. Licuria
20. Johnson
21. Freeborn
22. Molloy
23. L Davis
24. Rintoul
25. Lane
26. Dimattina
27. Kinnear
28. Shaw
29. Wasley
30. Mckee
31. Scotland
32. Ukovic
33. Tuckey
34. Cloke
35. Roach
36. Baynes
37. Richards
38. Stone
Fradam Wrote This
1. Tarrant
2. Buckley
3. N Davis
4. Fraser
5. Adkins
6. Burns
7. Rocca
8. Richardson
9. Lockyer
10. Lonie
11. Prestigiacomo
12. Didak
13. Wakelin
14. Betheras
15. Steinfort
16. O'Bree
17. Holland
18. Clement
19. Licuria
20. Johnson
21. Freeborn
22. Molloy
23. L Davis
24. Rintoul
25. Lane
26. Dimattina
27. Kinnear
28. Shaw
29. Wasley
30. Mckee
31. Scotland
32. Ukovic
33. Tuckey
34. Cloke
35. Roach
36. Baynes
37. Richards
38. Stone
Fradam Wrote This
-
Broadie
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 1999 8:01 pm
- Location: VIC
Fradam - how is O'Bree not in the top 10 (or top 5)?
Of the players above him, only 4 (Tarrant, Buckley, Fraser, Burns) could be said to absolutely have been better over time and this year, but Burnsy's injury worries would place him below.
While Davis & Lockyer are debatable, all the others are of lesser value (Adkins, Rocca, Richardson, Prestigiacomo, Wakelin, Betheras, Steinfort) or far too inexperienced and unproven (Lonie, Didak).
Broadie
Of the players above him, only 4 (Tarrant, Buckley, Fraser, Burns) could be said to absolutely have been better over time and this year, but Burnsy's injury worries would place him below.
While Davis & Lockyer are debatable, all the others are of lesser value (Adkins, Rocca, Richardson, Prestigiacomo, Wakelin, Betheras, Steinfort) or far too inexperienced and unproven (Lonie, Didak).
Broadie
-
Fradam
- Posts: 1487
- Joined: Mon Jun 21, 1999 6:01 pm
- Location: Bendigo, Victoria
I knew having O'Bree so low would get me in trouble. Let me explain why I have players above him.
Adkins - the guy is all class and he takes them on.
Rocca - he can win a match off his ownboot.
Richardson - he never plays a bad game, runs hard and backs himself.
Lockyer - kicks goals and has great disposal.
Lonie - I've probably got him too low I reckon, he's kicking goals from the half back line which is very valuable.
Presti - gets the most out of his ability, works and tries hard.
Didak - reads the play well and has excellent disposal.
Wakelin - does a great job, runs hard from defence.
Betheras - puts his body on the line and goes hard.
Steinfort - shuts down the oppositions best midfielder each week.
I'm very harsh on O'Bree I know. Last week his was great but i get frustrated when he turns the ball over. He's skills arnt that great, he tends to throw the ball on the boot without looking and when under pressure tends to make mistakes and his decision making isnt that flash. Having said that he does get a lot of the footy. I've put guys above him like Adkins and Didak coz I think they'll be better players in the future and their skill level is higher. So I've put guys with a higher skill level above O'Bree, the others I've put above him are guys who kick goals and guys who try their guts out every week and never let us down.I said in my original post that I play favourites and I do. O'Bree just frustrates me when I watch him.
Fradam Wrote This
Adkins - the guy is all class and he takes them on.
Rocca - he can win a match off his ownboot.
Richardson - he never plays a bad game, runs hard and backs himself.
Lockyer - kicks goals and has great disposal.
Lonie - I've probably got him too low I reckon, he's kicking goals from the half back line which is very valuable.
Presti - gets the most out of his ability, works and tries hard.
Didak - reads the play well and has excellent disposal.
Wakelin - does a great job, runs hard from defence.
Betheras - puts his body on the line and goes hard.
Steinfort - shuts down the oppositions best midfielder each week.
I'm very harsh on O'Bree I know. Last week his was great but i get frustrated when he turns the ball over. He's skills arnt that great, he tends to throw the ball on the boot without looking and when under pressure tends to make mistakes and his decision making isnt that flash. Having said that he does get a lot of the footy. I've put guys above him like Adkins and Didak coz I think they'll be better players in the future and their skill level is higher. So I've put guys with a higher skill level above O'Bree, the others I've put above him are guys who kick goals and guys who try their guts out every week and never let us down.I said in my original post that I play favourites and I do. O'Bree just frustrates me when I watch him.
Fradam Wrote This
-
Danzy Rocks!!!
- Posts: 811
- Joined: Sat May 12, 2001 6:01 pm