Brock McLean

[themonk]

Excellent, the only one I disagree with is Blair. If we had a decent side then Blair would be in & out of the side, depending on the opposition, the weather, the game etc.....He is not a definite starter and whether it was due to injuries or not I like you am unclear as to why he played all season.

The other two are show ponies.

[AN_Inkling]

if you want to be merciless about things, you would ask - 'is he better for us than say, XYZ' and if he is, then get rid of XYZ, and take him instead.

without naming names, we have a few list cloggers left

Except McLean's also old and an ex-Carlton player.

[Collingwood Crackerjack]

I think the idea has merit.

An old head amongst an old squad, and he can look after the young 'uns when they go out on a Saturday night, make sure he copes the flogging rather than them.

He play for beer money as well