This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker on our website.
RudeBoy wrote:He showed some real promise tonight. Hope he continues to improve, grow in confidence....and put on a few kilos of muscle.
Weight he doesn't need, but the strength that comes with physical maturity and working in the gym will come.
Andy Krakouer was built like a jockey. When you saw him up close and personal he looked like you could break him in half with a sneeze, but in close he could get the ball.
Best game so far for the kid and he'll only get better.
Every dead body on Mt Everest was once a highly motivated person, so maybe just calm the **** down.
I agree Dave - he was nearly in my top 5, but went missing a little as the game wore on. Looks classy off both feet, which i like, too. Growing in confidence and poise.
Mugwump wrote:I agree Dave - he was nearly in my top 5, but went missing a little as the game wore on. Looks classy off both feet, which i like, too. Growing in confidence and poise.
Might need to get Fitter to ge5 more Involved.
Building since coming back from VFL. Been exciting
I don't understand the love for Aish. IMO he does a few ok things like hit a target, but, he simply does not get involved enough and ball watches too much. This is the real issue, not his small size and lack of legs, for a mid he is not aggressive enough for mine, has no presence. Opposition does not pay him any attention or respect, he places no fear or concern into the minds of the opposition, it"s like he isn't even out there.......like Cloke tonight, mister invisible.
RED "BABY" CAVANAUGH: Didn't hear what the bet was.
Monco Matt wrote:I don't understand the love for Aish. IMO he does a few ok things like hit a target, but, he simply does not get involved enough and ball watches too much. This is the real issue, not his small size and lack of legs, for a mid he is not aggressive enough for mine, has no presence. Opposition does not pay him any attention or respect, he places no fear or concern into the minds of the opposition, it"s like he isn't even out there.......like Cloke tonight, mister invisible.
Would you rather players who try hard but are Turn over Machines?
Monco Matt wrote:I don't understand the love for Aish. IMO he does a few ok things like hit a target, but, he simply does not get involved enough and ball watches too much. This is the real issue, not his small size and lack of legs, for a mid he is not aggressive enough for mine, has no presence. Opposition does not pay him any attention or respect, he places no fear or concern into the minds of the opposition, it"s like he isn't even out there.......like Cloke tonight, mister invisible.
Would you rather players who try hard but are Turn over Machines?
Don't want Aish bottom of packs.
Guess you don't look hard for Aish then.
Building well since coming back from VFL
I like mids that are big and powerful or skilled ball magnets, Aish is neither IMO. I don't rate him, neither did the Lions. Doesn't do enough, maybe expectations on him are too high, I don't think he will become this awesome A-grader that many think. Hope to be proven wrong. Might be a Tambling.
RED "BABY" CAVANAUGH: Didn't hear what the bet was.
Monco Matt wrote:I don't understand the love for Aish. IMO he does a few ok things like hit a target, but, he simply does not get involved enough and ball watches too much. This is the real issue, not his small size and lack of legs, for a mid he is not aggressive enough for mine, has no presence. Opposition does not pay him any attention or respect, he places no fear or concern into the minds of the opposition, it"s like he isn't even out there.......like Cloke tonight, mister invisible.
Would you rather players who try hard but are Turn over Machines?
Don't want Aish bottom of packs.
Guess you don't look hard for Aish then.
Building well since coming back from VFL
I like mids that are big and powerful or skilled ball magnets, Aish is neither IMO. I don't rate him, neither did the Lions. Doesn't do enough, maybe expectations on him are too high, I don't think he will become this awesome A-grader that many think. Hope to be proven wrong. Might be a Tambling.
Think you expecting too much too soon.
Aish is better then Tambling.
I am not saying he be our Best 3 Player or anything like that but can have a long Career being a very good player. In the 5-10 best player in our List
Great to see the boy gaining experience within the team. I think he's fast becoming what we got him for. Forget that he's not a rampaging brute who smashes into everything he's more than that. He's bravery and toughness is unquestionably and has outstanding awareness.
A touch of class in most of everything he does.
