Post Match. Pies lose to Hawks - All comments please

[PyreneesPie]

Ah well.

Good games back from Cox and Thomas. Also good games from Adams, Fasolo and De Goey. Improvement from Moore

Same players failing us week in week out. For me Will HE, Broomhead and Ramsay just aren't up to it. They can join Aish permanently in the reserves IMO.

Phllips also not there yet, but might come on as he's still young.

.

I thought Crisp was good too.

[winpies]

Jeez I thought Phillips was pretty ordinary today, but the prize surely has to got to Sidebottom, some of those kicks were beyond description

Finaly! Sidebottom has his brilliant moments but those dinky little kicks of his can be atrocious. He is so frustrating to watch.

[mudlark]

Congratulations on your 250th Pendles. You were putrid today. You spilled a soda and they kicked 2 in a minute from that easy mark .If Broomhead and Phillips play again I'm surrendering my membership.I wouldn't pay 2 bob to watch these 2 spuds play.Don't EVER leave Reid out again and if Scharenberg leaves the club because of the wankers who are in charge, so do I. I'm over this shit.6 years is way too long to keep the heart warm. A disgusting coaching and selection effort and all need to be sacked.

[Raw Hammer]

The goal post (Elliott and Maynard) has sealed Buckley's fate. We're 14th FFS. Time to announce his departure at season's end.

[winpies]

The goal post (Elliott and Maynard) has sealed Buckley's fate. We're 14th FFS. Time to announce his departure at season's end.

Try 15th

[Collingwood Crackerjack]

Congratulations on your 250th Pendles. You were putrid today. You spilled a soda and they kicked 2 in a minute from that easy mark .If Broomhead and Phillips play again I'm surrendering my membership.I wouldn't pay 2 bob to watch these 2 spuds play.Don't EVER leave Reid out again and if Scharenberg leaves the club because of the wankers who are in charge, so do I. I'm over this shit.6 years is way too long to keep the heart warm. A disgusting coaching and selection effort and all need to be sacked.

Slinging shit on the Captain on his 250th: Classy.

He was hardly on his own in terms of bad play

[slangman]

It the game structure that has been killing us during buckleys reign.

That's why no matter which players we recruit, we will not go up the ladder.

Yes there are the occasional flashes of excitement, but the facts prove that a gameplan that mans up space instead of players doesn't work.

....and don't even begin to tell me that all teams do it.

[jatsad]

Same old turnovers.
Sam old shit kicks.
Same old shit handballs.
Same old players repeatedly making the same old mistakes.

But Bucks says we've improved.

With 4 minutes to go and only 2 goals down, we had the ball on the edge of the centre square in our front half. What happens next? They go backwards, backwards and backwards again until they succeed in turning it over.

Greenwood will only ever be a tagger. But Bucks thinks he can make a half forward out of him while Mitchell runs free racking up over 30 and 2 goals in the last quarter. After getting 50 the last time, you think he would have learned

I've had enough.

[thompsoc]

Bux let Hodge be the spare man in defence.
Not once and I repeat not once did ge do anything about him.
Just left him loose for the f...king entire game.
So Hodge marshalled the troups all day long.
And have we seen tbat before?
Yep yep and yep.
what is it now Clarko 10 Bux 1.
Hawthorn were crap.
Their disposal were pathetic.
But they still beat us.
Sick of the fools who still back Bux.
And there are plenty on this board.

[ANNODAM]

ESS next week too - good luck winning after their 2 humiliating losses, they'll be hungry!

[melliot]

More of the same. Hawks are bottom 4 and we can't beat them. Says it all.

We are simply no good. Play poor team football. And I'm just sick of watching our self destruction during a game.

Is there any chance we can have an improving season? It been a slow 6 year death.

Believe it or not, we are having another backwards year. Worse than the last two.

DeGoey had a good game. But has some defensive flaws to get right if he wants to be A grade.

Not sure what else there is to get excited about.

[think positive]

It the game structure that has been killing us during buckleys reign.

That's why no matter which players we recruit, we will not go up the ladder.

Yes there are the occasional flashes of excitement, but the facts prove that a gameplan that mans up space instead of players doesn't work.

....and don't even begin to tell me that all teams do it.

I agree totally. And leaving their forward 50 vacant again cost us two goals
I hate that crap

[mudlark]

Congratulations on your 250th Pendles. You were putrid today. You spilled a soda and they kicked 2 in a minute from that easy mark .If Broomhead and Phillips play again I'm surrendering my membership.I wouldn't pay 2 bob to watch these 2 spuds play.Don't EVER leave Reid out again and if Scharenberg leaves the club because of the wankers who are in charge, so do I. I'm over this shit.6 years is way too long to keep the heart warm. A disgusting coaching and selection effort and all need to be sacked.

Slinging shit on the Captain on his 250th: Classy.

He was hardly on his own in terms of bad play

So you obviously agree. I'll reiterate.He was putrid.As were many.I've supported this club for 64 years and this is even worse than Weidaman and Shaw put together.I know a shit game when I see one and you can sook all you like.He dropped a soda,30mtrs out that would have given us a 2 goal lead instead the opposition crumbed that dropped soda and kicked 2 goals in minute. NOT good enough from a 250 CAPTAIN!! Get over it sunshine.

[Wokko]

Hawks kicking it around the boundary, forcing contests and making it hard to go inboard while playing a spare man in defence. It's Mick Malthouses gameplan that Buckley saw every single day while assistant. He had no answer even though that gameplan was demolished in 2011.

Benched our most effective player when the game was there to win.

Left an AA swing man out to play Cox (admittedly did quite well, but he's no Reid).

Still wont play Scharenberg.. wut

Pendles in the Ruck with the game on the line... wut

Howe having a shocker (can happen to anyone), let's give him a crucial kick in... wut

etc. etc. etc.

[Heater_39]

Weak as piss

Drop Sidebottom I'm sick of his shot