#22 Steele Sidebottom

[Pies4shaw]

Only morons, Mr Miyagi, only actual morons.

[orie]

Surely people can't say Sidey played well tonight. The quality of disposals from players like Crisp Maynard Grundy and even Pendles tonight was shocking.
At one stage the disposal efficiency was 48%.

I just wonder is this Bucks fault?
Or has the off season just stripped players of confidence in each other..Maynards toughness has also gone out the window. What the hell is going on?

[think positive]

He may not have played well, but he was better than most. I’ve been hard on hm, about the covid shit and the baby, however, if the trade shit is true, then I’m pissed off, just another reason why bux should walk, or be pushed, now.

[Pies4shaw]

He's one of about 5 players you'd pick on form after last night's debacle.

[think positive]

He's one of about 5 players you'd pick on form after last night's debacle.

Agree - I only voted for 4 this week

[Ronnie McKeowns boots]

How many years until him, Pendles and Howe are gone? Dark times ahead

[orie]

Can people and the media not just look at number of disposals as an indicator of player's impact on the game.

Players like Sidey Crisp Maynard and even Miho are having 40% to 50% kicking
efficiency.. That's pretty ordinary. Even Pendles was at 50% last night.
WTF!!!
What is the point of getting the ball if they can't use it well.

Whose fault is that? I don't know if its the coach"s.
I hasten to add that Treloar got 3 votes with a kicking off in the low 40s.

[eddiesmith]

30 possessions, no goals, superstar
36 possessions, 2 goals, hack

Interesting...

[Rosolino_Leone]

30 possessions, no goals, superstar
36 possessions, 2 goals, hack

Interesting...

Brayden Sier on Gastro could run through that Geelong midfield atm

Until Petracca has 1 big final, he ain't a Superstar

And he needs to be much more consistant to be regarded Elite.

Today was a great performance ( you forgot to mention 9 clearences )

But I can point to a game where Josh Thomas had 36 touches and 3 goals

[Rosolino_Leone]

^
Much like Dane Swan had to earn his right of being called a Superstar. Petracca is like a 08-09 Dane Swan

[eddiesmith]

So Geelong is terrible yet they beat Brisbane, so where does that leave Collingwood?

[Rd10.1998_11.1#36]

Treloar is not a victim - he’s still getting his full contract (circa $900k) of which we’re still paying $300k for the next 5 years

More like $200k according to the Age https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/ada ... 56mtl.html

[think positive]

So Geelong is terrible yet they beat Brisbane, so where does that leave Collingwood?

gggeeezus ****, we lost after the siren, to a shitty call

altohugh we shouldnt have lost from 5 goals up.

geebung are never shit, they come back to haunt you, there are evil spirits there

[qldmagpie67]

Interesting that after 3 games (he missed round 1) Sidey hasn’t been allocated a single vote by our coach or the opposition coach
Conversely his direct opponent at the start of match in rounds 3 & 4 have both been awarded votes by both coaches

[eddiesmith]

But Sidey is one of our best...

It’s interesting to see some posters defend so vigorously players with zero commitment to the club or trying to win a premiership.

May fit in with the Buckley supporters who apparently also don’t think trying to win a premiership is actually the clubs goal.