Post Match. Pies win for Bucks. All comments, please.

[Rd10.1998_11.1#36]

De Goey offered a one week ban for rough conduct on Oliver

Cool, he can have the bye off

[KenH]

Disagree Ken, thats as hard as you can get a bloke for a week nowadays

Have another look at it Ronnie, I really don't think he connected?

[Alex]

Collingwood won the clearances by 10, 34 to 24. They won centre clearances 14 to 9 (and I think they won 4 of the 5 in the last quarter) and stoppage clearances 20 to 15.

Clearances - De Goey 6, Crisp, Pendlebury and Sidebottom 5, Daicos 3.

Centre clearances - De Goey 5, Sidebottom 3, Pendlebury 2 and 5 others 1 each.

This without Adams and even Grundy is very impressive.

We played fantastically, Pendles was great, best game this year for him, the same to De Goey, a shame that he could miss next game, hopefully they can continue on this form, especially De Goey. Maynard had his best game for the season which has still been a good one for him, he has been a reliable lockdown defender for us this year but he was really damaging today offensively. The future is exciting and we still need to add Nick Daicos to this young core.

Just to add, great game from Lynch. My perspective on him has done a complete 180 turn. I thought he should have been delisted last year, and even dropped for this match, but he showed that he has some talent as a tap ruckman, which is really the only flaw in Grundy's game. We should keep him and trade Cox this trade period I think.

[RudeBoy]

The club should contest De Goey's charge. It's clear that Jordy just managed to pull out of fully connecting Oliver, which is why Oliver got straight up.

[slangman]

Tim Kelly concussed JDG with a hip to the head and got off.
Can’t see why De Goey was given a week.

[Charlie Oneeye]

Good Point

I saw it briefly.. and note.. this is what I perceived before my wife grabbed my attention... else I was going to Die!

DeGoey lined him up and was going to do a Brereton to him. Didn't happen, but I don't think the AFL likes players attempting to take other players out.

[Swanny2011]

Can’t see why De Goey was given a week.

De Goey ran passed the ball deliberately to take out the player with a hip an shoulder. De Goey hit him with significant force. Sorry but generally any player that does that these days will get suspended.
I think this is an open and shut case and it will be pointless appealing.

The interesting case will be the Mckay case.

[BazBoy]

[What'sinaname]

Can’t see why De Goey was given a week.

De Goey ran passed the ball deliberately to take out the player with a hip an shoulder. De Goey hit him with significant force. Sorry but generally any player that does that these days will get suspended.
I think this is an open and shut case and it will be pointless appealing.

The interesting case will be the Mckay case.

Correct

[Ronnie McKeowns boots]

Disagree Ken, thats as hard as you can get a bloke for a week nowadays

Have another look at it Ronnie, I really don't think he connected?

But even the slightest of contact, given the aggressive go past the ball nature of the bump, was going to get a week....as for its effect, have a look at old mates face when he gets up, absolutely shat himself, and was hearing footsteps for the rest of the game....well worth a week

[BazBoy]

That’s what I said. Maybe overzealous and not in duty of care area

Attack the ball carrier fiercely and constantly then the side has doubts as to

“am I gunna get driven into the deck and regular-it’s gunna hurt”

We had them

[i hate carlton]

Disgraceful decision - the club should appeal.

[Dave The Man]

Disgraceful decision - the club should appeal.

They Haven't

Oliver is a Flopper

[BazBoy]

[Rd10.1998_11.1#36]

Oliver is a Flopper

They don't call him Clayton Fallover for nothing