This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker on our website.
This is a Collingwood Bulletin Board - use this forum for general, Pies-related topics. For other footy topics, use Nick's Other AFL forum, and for non-footy sporting topics please use Nick's Sports Bar. For non-sporting topics please use the Victoria Park Tavern.
Swanny2011 wrote:We should look at trading WHE. Would most likely hold a higher trade value than some players already mentioned (as he is just a tease) and provides Collingwood very little game day value. Someone at the top end of the ladder may be interested.
I agree. Remember, he is on very big coin, so trading him would fast-track our ability to recruit a free agent.
At his best, WHE is a great player, but he has been terribly inconsistent, and his best form was 3 yrs ago. Although I like him as a player, I must admit I'd prefer a player with a harder edge to his game. We need to toughen up all over the ground.
Does anyone know how long Hoss’s contract has to run and the coin he’s earning over that time?
magpieazza wrote:If I had a gun pointed at my head and someone said "trade 2 young fellas"
I would look at IQ and Callum Brown.
I would only trade IQ if he would be worth a first rounder....does anyone here think he is worth that?
CB would be worth something around pick 20-30 ?
Please dont take this seriously as I would prefer if they stayed and became great players for us but if I had to pick someone that could be worth something, it would be these two, hypothetically speaking of course.
I would get in 2 x midfielders and no talls, but thats just me.
What's the point of trading IQ for a first rounder. It would get swallowed up by the Daicos bid than you've lost a 10 year player.
MJ23 wrote:Also, we have actually passed on a few we did not rate
Namely Jake Kelly at Cows, and Stewart at Doperland.
More of Hine's ineptitude laid bare for the football world to see.
Kelly was very average for years and Stewart did SFA at GWS
We passed on Weiderman and posters still have a hard on for him in spite of his obvious shitness
We did not pass on Wiederman. We were forced to use our first draft selection for Moore then Melbourne selected him at 8.
piedys wrote:
Namely Jake Kelly at Cows, and Stewart at Doperland.
More of Hine's ineptitude laid bare for the football world to see.
Kelly was very average for years and Stewart did SFA at GWS
We passed on Weiderman and posters still have a hard on for him in spite of his obvious shitness
We did not pass on Wiederman. We were forced to use our first draft selection for Moore then Melbourne selected him at 8.
MJ23 wrote:^ aside from trusting North with N. Daicos future - which no way in hell Id do.
Ive seen and heard of a lot less being called draft tampering.
Fair point. Daicos at potentially four would warrant a National enquiry
Four legged animals good, two legged animals better
MJ23 wrote:^ aside from trusting North with N. Daicos future - which no way in hell Id do.
Ive seen and heard of a lot less being called draft tampering.
Fair point. Daicos at potentially four would warrant a National enquiry
Four legged animals good, two legged animals better
MJ23 wrote:^ aside from trusting North with N. Daicos future - which no way in hell Id do.
Ive seen and heard of a lot less being called draft tampering.
Fair point. Daicos at potentially four would warrant a National enquiry
Last edited by Pies2016 on Mon Aug 30, 2021 5:30 pm, edited 2 times in total.
