The 2021 Great Big Consolidated Trade & Draft thread
Moderator: bbmods
- Rd10.1998_11.1#36
- Posts: 2542
- Joined: Wed Jul 18, 2018 7:04 pm
- Location: Sevilla, Spain
- Has liked: 14 times
- Been liked: 5 times
- MJ23
- Posts: 4163
- Joined: Mon Feb 28, 2011 8:52 pm
- Location: Sydney
^ you know, Ive been against the Weed from the start - as a forward. Ive said a few times Id prefer Brander and develop the kids we have now - Kelly, Begg, McMahon
Someone suggested looking at him as a defender and Ive totally changed my mind. We need another elite Tall in defense. Howe and Roughy wont be around when our current kids + Daicos peak. Keely/Keene/Wilson maybe but none have cemented a spot. Weed could be the Ben Reid type conversion we are looking for - still need him cheap.
I know we need a spearhead - but we also need to sure up talls in the back half and another 2 at least 30+ possession midfielder's which hopefully come from our current kids.
Someone suggested looking at him as a defender and Ive totally changed my mind. We need another elite Tall in defense. Howe and Roughy wont be around when our current kids + Daicos peak. Keely/Keene/Wilson maybe but none have cemented a spot. Weed could be the Ben Reid type conversion we are looking for - still need him cheap.
I know we need a spearhead - but we also need to sure up talls in the back half and another 2 at least 30+ possession midfielder's which hopefully come from our current kids.
"Even when Im old and gray, I wont be able to play but Ill still love the game"
Michael Jordan
Michael Jordan
^ ^ ^
Thanks
So Carlton are also into Hewett and Cerra. One is a significant trade and both are significant contracts. I’d be shocked if they could pull off all three off ( and they also need to spin their long suffering supporters something positive )
Subject to the trade involved, I’d be happy for Lipinski to make his way to Collingwood. He’s a decent player who can’t a game in the deepest midfield in the comp. Good size, versatile, perfect age demographic and neat skills. What’s not to like.
Thanks
So Carlton are also into Hewett and Cerra. One is a significant trade and both are significant contracts. I’d be shocked if they could pull off all three off ( and they also need to spin their long suffering supporters something positive )
Subject to the trade involved, I’d be happy for Lipinski to make his way to Collingwood. He’s a decent player who can’t a game in the deepest midfield in the comp. Good size, versatile, perfect age demographic and neat skills. What’s not to like.
We are approaching a good football department with well thought of personal
like Graham Wright and Craig McRae and soon Leppitsch which IMHO will help our PR and if this Bulldog mid nominates us then more may follow
Just tweak Admin / Board and the whole landscape could change for the better
like Graham Wright and Craig McRae and soon Leppitsch which IMHO will help our PR and if this Bulldog mid nominates us then more may follow
Just tweak Admin / Board and the whole landscape could change for the better
I'm not arguing--just explaining why i am right
- MatthewBoydFanClub
- Posts: 5559
- Joined: Mon Feb 12, 2007 7:02 pm
- Location: Elwood
- Been liked: 1 time
The advantage we have is that Lipinski at 23 would just walk straight into our midfield setup. If he goes to Carlton and Carlton also get Cerra I wouldn't think there's any guarantee Lipinski would get a game at Carlton. That fixes the big bodied mid that we need. Next. A key position forward to find aged around 22-25. That's going to be much harder to find.Pies2016 wrote:^ ^ ^
Thanks
So Carlton are also into Hewett and Cerra. One is a significant trade and both are significant contracts. I’d be shocked if they could pull off all three off ( and they also need to spin their long suffering supporters something positive )
Subject to the trade involved, I’d be happy for Lipinski to make his way to Collingwood. He’s a decent player who can’t a game in the deepest midfield in the comp. Good size, versatile, perfect age demographic and neat skills. What’s not to like.
Totally.MatthewBoydFanClub wrote:The advantage we have is that Lipinski at 23 would just walk straight into our midfield setup. If he goes to Carlton and Carlton also get Cerra I wouldn't think there's any guarantee Lipinski would get a game at Carlton. That fixes the big bodied mid that we need. Next. A key position forward to find aged around 22-25. That's going to be much harder to find.Pies2016 wrote:^ ^ ^
Thanks
So Carlton are also into Hewett and Cerra. One is a significant trade and both are significant contracts. I’d be shocked if they could pull off all three off ( and they also need to spin their long suffering supporters something positive )
Subject to the trade involved, I’d be happy for Lipinski to make his way to Collingwood. He’s a decent player who can’t a game in the deepest midfield in the comp. Good size, versatile, perfect age demographic and neat skills. What’s not to like.
Wright is into the Weid and apparently he’s keen.
People seem divided on his fitness/ability but he fits our needs…
- Podpicken
- Posts: 2092
- Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 8:05 pm
I actually reckon it's THE perfect time to get the Weid as a good punt.
He's actually ready to roll, was really stringing great games together in the VFL this year (despite not grabbing his opportunities). He's developed body wise now, and 2022 is the season he's due to take the next step. Otherwise I agree with comments previously about transforming him into a defender.
From memory, Josh Kennedy took about 4-5 years to settle into becoming a solid key forward kicking a decent amount of goals. The Weid (I think) has played 5 seasons. They're both the same height, similar weight.
I reckon it's worth a punt.
He's actually ready to roll, was really stringing great games together in the VFL this year (despite not grabbing his opportunities). He's developed body wise now, and 2022 is the season he's due to take the next step. Otherwise I agree with comments previously about transforming him into a defender.
From memory, Josh Kennedy took about 4-5 years to settle into becoming a solid key forward kicking a decent amount of goals. The Weid (I think) has played 5 seasons. They're both the same height, similar weight.
I reckon it's worth a punt.
Billy Picken, the great No. 25 in the sky!