Reserves:
GOALS:
Williamstown: Clark 5 Crawford 3 Keddell Beaumont
BEST:
Williamstown: Crawford Miller Lockwood Keddell Foley Chiu
REPORTED PLAYERS:
Williamstown: B.Quinn (65) reported by Field Umpire Faoro and Goal Umpire Maggenti for striking G.Johnstone (24) in the fourth quarter.
http://reg.sportingpulse.com/olr_v3/rpt ... 20Reserves
TV Saturday April 14th
Moderator: bbmods
-
WKB
- Posts: 603
- Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 1:22 pm
It was an appalling game by most at Williamstown, really didn't deserve anything from the game (though it's Port so we'll take it).
Bit of controversy at the end for those at the game, though the scoreboard had Towners in front, everyone knew he'd had put down Willo's touched kick as a goal. Despite that there wasn't anyone at the ground who didn't have Port by a point at the final siren, JAJH asked up at the ABC box and it was then we were told they had it as a draw, so everyone stuck around and watched as the umpires checked their scores.
There really wasn't much to write home about as far as the Collingwood listed players. Disposal was atrocious and the want to chase and pick up players was non-existent to the point of embarrassment.
someone said Wellingham should be in the best, being at the game I agree totally with Dale61, didn't do enough often enough.
After quarter time Reid looked lost, Ben Davies disposal and decision making was shocking, the amount of times he set his teammates up to be crunched was poor.
Nicholls ran all day and he will never give in but again disposal let him down.
Mcaffer fleeted in and out of it but far from our worse, but by the same token really didn't have an impact.
Marty Clarke couldn't do many things right, seem to be having one of those games, but his ability to know what's around him has to improve. As does the respect for opponents. When he got caught by Dukes it was complete lack of respect. Now to be fair he wouldn't know the workrate of Dukes etc but Clarke ambled off as if he had days and never looked behind as he assumed a bloke as big as Dukes wouldn't chase, let alone catch him.
Goldsack was the shining light, was given a rough run from the umpires, if he gave the attention to the forwards that they gave him in regards to over the shoulder and pushes and chopping arms, he'd have 10 kicked on him, but no he's the backman so it was fairplay. But he's strong, backs himself, good overhead and follows everything up. More importantly he keeps his feet.
Stanley was a non-factor.
Cook had a brief moment in that third quarter when we got level where he moved ok but really didn't do much.
It was the VFL players that stood up today and kept us in it, johnson, greene, Willo, Picken, Proctor.
And don't worry about the blokes at port who we got rid of. Fanning played like fanning, he's honest but still not that good (though he's lost a bout 20kg).
Rowe is still a soft touch, it was our lack of chasing or picking players up, he just sat on that wing all day, never went near a contest and just got cheap touches not one of which he earnt on his own. And the one time we got to him and actually pressured him he shat himself and got caught holding the ball (or should of but luckily this year he was playing for port not williamstown or he would have had a free kick against him).
Bit of controversy at the end for those at the game, though the scoreboard had Towners in front, everyone knew he'd had put down Willo's touched kick as a goal. Despite that there wasn't anyone at the ground who didn't have Port by a point at the final siren, JAJH asked up at the ABC box and it was then we were told they had it as a draw, so everyone stuck around and watched as the umpires checked their scores.
There really wasn't much to write home about as far as the Collingwood listed players. Disposal was atrocious and the want to chase and pick up players was non-existent to the point of embarrassment.
someone said Wellingham should be in the best, being at the game I agree totally with Dale61, didn't do enough often enough.
After quarter time Reid looked lost, Ben Davies disposal and decision making was shocking, the amount of times he set his teammates up to be crunched was poor.
Nicholls ran all day and he will never give in but again disposal let him down.
Mcaffer fleeted in and out of it but far from our worse, but by the same token really didn't have an impact.
Marty Clarke couldn't do many things right, seem to be having one of those games, but his ability to know what's around him has to improve. As does the respect for opponents. When he got caught by Dukes it was complete lack of respect. Now to be fair he wouldn't know the workrate of Dukes etc but Clarke ambled off as if he had days and never looked behind as he assumed a bloke as big as Dukes wouldn't chase, let alone catch him.
Goldsack was the shining light, was given a rough run from the umpires, if he gave the attention to the forwards that they gave him in regards to over the shoulder and pushes and chopping arms, he'd have 10 kicked on him, but no he's the backman so it was fairplay. But he's strong, backs himself, good overhead and follows everything up. More importantly he keeps his feet.
Stanley was a non-factor.
Cook had a brief moment in that third quarter when we got level where he moved ok but really didn't do much.
It was the VFL players that stood up today and kept us in it, johnson, greene, Willo, Picken, Proctor.
And don't worry about the blokes at port who we got rid of. Fanning played like fanning, he's honest but still not that good (though he's lost a bout 20kg).
Rowe is still a soft touch, it was our lack of chasing or picking players up, he just sat on that wing all day, never went near a contest and just got cheap touches not one of which he earnt on his own. And the one time we got to him and actually pressured him he shat himself and got caught holding the ball (or should of but luckily this year he was playing for port not williamstown or he would have had a free kick against him).
-
Johnson#26
- Posts: 24763
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 6:54 am
-
jeff corfe
-
Dale61
- Posts: 7379
- Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 6:01 pm
- Location: /home/room/chair
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/ ... 95,00.html
Gotch praised former Richmond list player Dean Limbach who booted six goals from seven possessions.
Upset by the treatment he received at Punt Rd, the former Calder Cannons TAC Cup player aims to have a second shot at AFL next season.
Collingwood coach Mick Malthouse and injured skipper Nathan Buckley watched the match from the grandstand and would have been impressed by 17-year-old draft choice centre half-forward Ben Reid, 19-year-old defender Tyson Goldsack and rookies Martin Clarke, Ben Macaffer, Sharrod Wellingham and Dan Nicholls.
Seagulls stand-outs were Collingwood list player Ben Davies, skipper Brett Johnson and Steven Greene.
Whale
Oil
Beef
Hooked
Oil
Beef
Hooked
-
mickyg
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 4:20 pm
-
jeff corfe
Gotch was wrapped with the efforts from young macaffer!!WKB wrote:It was an appalling game by most at Williamstown, really didn't deserve anything from the game (though it's Port so we'll take it).
Bit of controversy at the end for those at the game, though the scoreboard had Towners in front, everyone knew he'd had put down Willo's touched kick as a goal. Despite that there wasn't anyone at the ground who didn't have Port by a point at the final siren, JAJH asked up at the ABC box and it was then we were told they had it as a draw, so everyone stuck around and watched as the umpires checked their scores.
There really wasn't much to write home about as far as the Collingwood listed players. Disposal was atrocious and the want to chase and pick up players was non-existent to the point of embarrassment.
someone said Wellingham should be in the best, being at the game I agree totally with Dale61, didn't do enough often enough.
After quarter time Reid looked lost, Ben Davies disposal and decision making was shocking, the amount of times he set his teammates up to be crunched was poor.
Nicholls ran all day and he will never give in but again disposal let him down.
Mcaffer fleeted in and out of it but far from our worse, but by the same token really didn't have an impact.
Marty Clarke couldn't do many things right, seem to be having one of those games, but his ability to know what's around him has to improve. As does the respect for opponents. When he got caught by Dukes it was complete lack of respect. Now to be fair he wouldn't know the workrate of Dukes etc but Clarke ambled off as if he had days and never looked behind as he assumed a bloke as big as Dukes wouldn't chase, let alone catch him.
Goldsack was the shining light, was given a rough run from the umpires, if he gave the attention to the forwards that they gave him in regards to over the shoulder and pushes and chopping arms, he'd have 10 kicked on him, but no he's the backman so it was fairplay. But he's strong, backs himself, good overhead and follows everything up. More importantly he keeps his feet.
Stanley was a non-factor.
Cook had a brief moment in that third quarter when we got level where he moved ok but really didn't do much.
It was the VFL players that stood up today and kept us in it, johnson, greene, Willo, Picken, Proctor.
And don't worry about the blokes at port who we got rid of. Fanning played like fanning, he's honest but still not that good (though he's lost a bout 20kg).
Rowe is still a soft touch, it was our lack of chasing or picking players up, he just sat on that wing all day, never went near a contest and just got cheap touches not one of which he earnt on his own. And the one time we got to him and actually pressured him he shat himself and got caught holding the ball (or should of but luckily this year he was playing for port not williamstown or he would have had a free kick against him).
-
WKB
- Posts: 603
- Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 1:22 pm
Yeah I'm not sure I said anything bad about him, plus they have the luxury of knowing what exact role they gave him and what they expected out of him during the game.joffa corfe wrote: Gotch was wrapped with the efforts from young macaffer!!
He was solid at the contests he was in but I just don't think, outside of Goldsack, that any of the Collingwood boys had any real impact games that grabbed you and said "They've earnt a senior spot for next week". It was a dire game full of errors.
To the person who asked about Iles. Sammy yesterday got a reasonable amount of the ball but he just didn't impose himself with the quality of possessions, the same I said about Davies.
One game doesn't maketh a player of course, these same players put in solid performances last week. Yesterday was just one of those games, kicks went to long or to short, a lot of players had the fumbles. Though there was a lot of players who weren't accountable at times.
Now Port I know is full of ex AFL players but aligned clubs really should perform much better against these stand alone teams and if we played to our potential they should not have got near us.
I'll put in a disclosure that i'm a little p*ssed at the result as Port Melbourne is the Carlton of the VFL to me, I hate them with every fibre of my being so anything but a win is not a satisfactory result for me.
-
jackcass
- Posts: 12529
- Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2005 1:17 pm
- Location: Bendigo
-
jackcass
- Posts: 12529
- Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2005 1:17 pm
- Location: Bendigo
Limbach is a funny one really. Thought he was flogged all day yet he managed 6 goals. Can't ask for much more than that.Dale61 wrote:Best for Williamstown: Johnson Meyer Goldsack Limbach Greene Davies.
http://reg.sportingpulse.com/olr_v3/rpt ... %20Seniors
Last edited by jackcass on Mon Apr 16, 2007 9:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
jackcass
- Posts: 12529
- Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2005 1:17 pm
- Location: Bendigo
Thought he was solid all day. Hard to see who he would displace from the senior line up at this stage.mickyg wrote:i thought that Iles was pretty solid, uses the ball well and is actually very quick, has to be close to selection. It amazes me that so many posters dont rate him and or leave him out of their player reveiws completly. dont supporters know who he is?