Ive just gone thru some posts and it seems some are not too enthusiastic regards this great clubs future.
Ponder this
sydneys last flag was 1933
melbournes 1964 v collingwood unfortunately
st kildas 1966 ditto
geelongs 1963
freeo,port power and brisbane nil ever
footscrays 1954
They are less succesful than us and are still going strong so why the sad faces.........look ahead its rosy.
By the way I reckon sav could have stayed on as a ruckman,he sure was better than stunning steve
its all ahead for the pies
Moderator: bbmods
-
ed healey
-
AlfAndrews
You've got an interesting technique of rewriting history. I liked the bit about Sydney's last flag being in 1933.
Funny? I didn't think Sydney joined the League until 1982. According to my records, a club called South Melbourne won the 1933 premiership. And as far as I'm aware, they don't exist any more.
And that club called "Footscray". Who are they? I agree they won the 1954 premiership. But whatever became of them?
Now, I agree that our Club has got a great record over the whole of its history. But I suppose the reason people like me get on the doom 'n' gloom thing is that our greatest achievements seem to be way back in the past. With the obvious exception of 1990, our record since 1982 has been appalling.
Geelong may not have won a flag since 1963, but they've played in a few Grand Finals since then and have been competitive a lot of the time. Melbourne's overall record since 1964 has been abysmal, but at least they've had a few good seasons in recent years, so their supporters have at least got some sense of hope.
As for Brisbane, Port and Freo: they are very new clubs and it will take them a long time to establish an AFL identity and history.
You could have also included the Western Bulldogs among that list of new clubs. Since they came into existence in 1997 they have failed to win a premiership. But at least they've been very consistent and competitive in their four years.
I agree that St.Kilda has a bad record ... even worse than ours. But they do at least have fairly recent Grand Final experience. And their recruiting of playing and coaching staff this summer has given their supporters some hope for next year.
But, hell. Who am I to spoil the party. The good thing about this part of the season is that we're still unbeaten. We're equal on the ladder with all the other clubs ... so at least we're a chance.
Ah, that good old Collingwood optimism!!!
------------------
**floreat pica**
Funny? I didn't think Sydney joined the League until 1982. According to my records, a club called South Melbourne won the 1933 premiership. And as far as I'm aware, they don't exist any more.
And that club called "Footscray". Who are they? I agree they won the 1954 premiership. But whatever became of them?
Now, I agree that our Club has got a great record over the whole of its history. But I suppose the reason people like me get on the doom 'n' gloom thing is that our greatest achievements seem to be way back in the past. With the obvious exception of 1990, our record since 1982 has been appalling.
Geelong may not have won a flag since 1963, but they've played in a few Grand Finals since then and have been competitive a lot of the time. Melbourne's overall record since 1964 has been abysmal, but at least they've had a few good seasons in recent years, so their supporters have at least got some sense of hope.
As for Brisbane, Port and Freo: they are very new clubs and it will take them a long time to establish an AFL identity and history.
You could have also included the Western Bulldogs among that list of new clubs. Since they came into existence in 1997 they have failed to win a premiership. But at least they've been very consistent and competitive in their four years.
I agree that St.Kilda has a bad record ... even worse than ours. But they do at least have fairly recent Grand Final experience. And their recruiting of playing and coaching staff this summer has given their supporters some hope for next year.
But, hell. Who am I to spoil the party. The good thing about this part of the season is that we're still unbeaten. We're equal on the ladder with all the other clubs ... so at least we're a chance.
Ah, that good old Collingwood optimism!!!
------------------
**floreat pica**
-
ed healey
-
London Dave
- Posts: 7172
- Joined: Wed Dec 16, 1998 7:01 pm
- Location: Iceland on Thames
- Contact:
-
AlfAndrews
Oh, no. Not the old "floreat pica" debate all over again!!!
I think we decided that it was supposed to mean "may the magpies prosper" or some such thing. But the real classical scholars (of whom I am not really one) pointed out that the Latin is actually incorrect. The person who made it up should have been made to write out their conjugation (or whatever you call it) a hundred times for using the verb in the singular and the noun in the plural.
And yes, I know we've played in a lot of Grand Finals. But only one in the last 19 years. And not a lot of other finals in that same period either.
Up to 1981 we were easily the most consistent Club in the League. Other clubs had their moments of glory ... but we were always there, never far away from the top. If only those days could return.
------------------
**floreat pica**
I think we decided that it was supposed to mean "may the magpies prosper" or some such thing. But the real classical scholars (of whom I am not really one) pointed out that the Latin is actually incorrect. The person who made it up should have been made to write out their conjugation (or whatever you call it) a hundred times for using the verb in the singular and the noun in the plural.
And yes, I know we've played in a lot of Grand Finals. But only one in the last 19 years. And not a lot of other finals in that same period either.
Up to 1981 we were easily the most consistent Club in the League. Other clubs had their moments of glory ... but we were always there, never far away from the top. If only those days could return.
------------------
**floreat pica**
-
Mike
- Posts: 3137
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 1996 7:01 pm
- Location: Lilydale, Tas.
- Has liked: 89 times
- Been liked: 26 times
I once asked Richard Stremski about floreat pica.
Here's his response:
http://www.magpies.org.au/nick/ubb/Forum1/HTML/000367.html
Here's his response:
http://www.magpies.org.au/nick/ubb/Forum1/HTML/000367.html
??? -
AlfAndrews
-
NICK THE PIE MAN
- Posts: 727
- Joined: Thu May 11, 2000 6:01 pm
- Location: Gold Coast, QLD
-
rhain
. Alf it was a joke, just everything message you write is over 100 words lol 
. And Joffa whats up with you, you have been funny lately 
-
nrb
-
Mike
- Posts: 3137
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 1996 7:01 pm
- Location: Lilydale, Tas.
- Has liked: 89 times
- Been liked: 26 times
Gday nrb - 12 months between posts, good to have you back.
I'm not sure what the meaning of your post is. I wrote to Richard Stremski back in May, to ask him to throw some light on the Club motto. It was his widely recognised and appreciated expertise as Club historian that I was asking for - nothing to do with his role as GM - a role he hasn't performed for 12 months anyway. All I've done this time is refer to his answer from then.
I'm not sure what the meaning of your post is. I wrote to Richard Stremski back in May, to ask him to throw some light on the Club motto. It was his widely recognised and appreciated expertise as Club historian that I was asking for - nothing to do with his role as GM - a role he hasn't performed for 12 months anyway. All I've done this time is refer to his answer from then.