Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:04 pm
Serves the blues right got royally screwed. Well done Carlton u dipsticks u get a pensioner on his last legs and a midfielder who they have a surplus for.
Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board
This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
https://magpies.net/
The consolidated Fev thread
Page 87 of 100
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:05 pm
Fev and Brown out on the piss together.... lol
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:11 pm
Is there forward line big enough for both there egos?
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:13 pm
Yikes!How are they going to fit those two egomaniacs into that club?There won't be enough room for the other players to fit in the dressing rooms with the egos of those two players.
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:14 pm
I hate Voss but I have to commend him on his willingness to take chances to improve his list. Time will tell if he's successful but at least he won't die wondering
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:28 pm
I agree - I think Voss has not waited but got the deals done that they wanted to do.
They can now sit back and watch.
They may also get X. CLark from the Saints as well and that may ease their salary cap pressure and allow them to keep Ball and Lovett.
They can now sit back and watch.
They may also get X. CLark from the Saints as well and that may ease their salary cap pressure and allow them to keep Ball and Lovett.
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:36 pm
Cant understand Carltons thinking if this goes through.
They gain:
31 yr old FF to add to Betts, Fisher, Gartlett. Wow that somehow just got worse.
Brock McLean, Michael Rischetelli to an already gun midfield that boasts Simpson, Gibbs, Judd, Murphy ect.
They lose:
Pick 11. This means they dont get the opportunity to get the best or second best forward in the draft to bolster the lean line up.
Fevola. The best FF in the league lol
They gain:
31 yr old FF to add to Betts, Fisher, Gartlett. Wow that somehow just got worse.
Brock McLean, Michael Rischetelli to an already gun midfield that boasts Simpson, Gibbs, Judd, Murphy ect.
They lose:
Pick 11. This means they dont get the opportunity to get the best or second best forward in the draft to bolster the lean line up.
Fevola. The best FF in the league lol
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:40 pm
me neither. Surely they would prefer a pick + a player like Dawes who is young and can be turned into anything.ad4eva wrote:Cant understand Carltons thinking if this goes through.
They gain:
31 yr old FF to add to Betts, Fisher, Gartlett. Wow that somehow just got worse.
Brock McLean, Michael Rischetelli to an already gun midfield that boasts Simpson, Gibbs, Judd, Murphy ect.
They lose:
Pick 11. This means they dont get the opportunity to get the best or second best forward in the draft to bolster the lean line up.
Fevola. The best FF in the league lol
If it goes ahead I hope Bradshaw's hamstring snaps in round 1
and I also hope Voss chokes on Browns brad dickPosted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:43 pm
Hopefully Brisbane can this deal done quick tomorrow and put everyone out if their misery.
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 6:51 pm
What I don't understand is Carltons window wont open for another 2 years without Fev imo. So why wouldn't they grab whatever picks they could.
They will tell you Bradshaw kicked 50 goals last year... but they are forgetting they don;t have JB to take all the focus off him.
They will tell you Bradshaw kicked 50 goals last year... but they are forgetting they don;t have JB to take all the focus off him.
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 7:03 pm
I enjoyed this off big footy...
Our trading strategies are majorly ****ed. Go jump of a cliff Icke & Swann - you've done nothing since the Judd deal and if Masten/Kennedy take the next step even that one will be a mistake. Brisbane end up with Fevola, Staker, Buchannan and Raines while giving away practically nothing. Meanwhile we trade our 1st rounder for a podder who Melbourne couldnt wait to give up and Fevola for yet another fringe midfielder and a player who will not be a part of our next flag (which is now at least 5 years away).
Our trading strategies are majorly ****ed. Go jump of a cliff Icke & Swann - you've done nothing since the Judd deal and if Masten/Kennedy take the next step even that one will be a mistake. Brisbane end up with Fevola, Staker, Buchannan and Raines while giving away practically nothing. Meanwhile we trade our 1st rounder for a podder who Melbourne couldnt wait to give up and Fevola for yet another fringe midfielder and a player who will not be a part of our next flag (which is now at least 5 years away).
Bradshaw and Rischatelli for Fevola
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 7:13 pm
If the above trade goes through, who do you think would be the winner?
Not sure why Brisbane would do this to be honest. Pretty ordinary for Carlton though, an ageing forward and a servicable midfielder.
is that really the best they can do?
Not sure why Brisbane would do this to be honest. Pretty ordinary for Carlton though, an ageing forward and a servicable midfielder.
is that really the best they can do?
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 7:15 pm
Just imagine the teeth gnashing about to happen over on the Carlscum board! Music to my ears....really! 
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 7:17 pm
Brisbane win hands down...
Carlton are Stupid!! as much as I would hate to see a forward line of Fevola & Brown I would love to see the scum forward line Bradshaw pfffttt Bradshaw is a prehistoric Dud.. never been any good at all.. not worth pick 87 let alone Fev
Carlton are Stupid!! as much as I would hate to see a forward line of Fevola & Brown I would love to see the scum forward line Bradshaw pfffttt Bradshaw is a prehistoric Dud.. never been any good at all.. not worth pick 87 let alone Fev
Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 7:20 pm
Brisbane, but not great for either. Would be happy for it to go through.