Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

Carr for rounds 1, 2 and 3! He is a good player but certainly not that good!

Agreed. Choco may be smarter than we've given him credit for in the Stevens deal last year. If Freo crumbled because they knew Choco would force Carr into the PSD, then it will have been worthwhile. Three picks is extortion, two would still have been too much and one pick would have been about right.

LOL 3 picks for carr, that is hilarious. Freo are a bunch of pansies, should have made Choco sweat it out

PiesFan wrote:LOL 3 picks for carr, that is hilarious. Freo are a bunch of pansies, should have made Choco sweat it out

exactly, freo had nothing to lose, port had a premiership player too lose

TuPaC wrote:

PiesFan wrote:LOL 3 picks for carr, that is hilarious. Freo are a bunch of pansies, should have made Choco sweat it out

exactly, freo had nothing to lose, port had a premiership player too lose

the funny thing is, its not like they need help in their midfield. They have a good midfield already. What they needed was a KPP, most preferably up forward to kick some goals instead of relying on their small forwards to win finals. If they had traded their 1st, 2nd and 3rd pick for a player of this mould, then at least i can see some reason behind it.

To give those picks away for a player who desperately wants to play in the same team as his brother and who would have most probably gone to the PSD if they didnt get him is insane! If only Bomber thompson traded like the Dorkers did.....