Scott Pendlebury (Silk)

[Donny]

Pies.

69 Scott Pendlebury
60 Dane Swan
37 Steele Sidebottom
32 Travis Cloke
23 Harry O'Brien
20 Heath Shaw
12 Sam Dwyer
11 Luke Ball,
10 Jamie Elliott
9 Paul Seedsman
7 Dale Thomas
5 Nathan Brown
4 Dayne Beams, Jarryd Blair, Quinten Lynch, Brent Macaffer
3 Ben Reid, Sinkers
2 Ben Kennedy, Marley Williams
1 Ben Hudson, Darren Jolly, Andrew Krakouer, Kyle Martin, Alan Toovey

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

Interesting, I wonder which coach gave Pendles the 5 votes? He must have been very annoyed the idiot!

The way I broke it down it looks like that 5 voter was the work of one coach btw

[Donny]

1 & 1 - Ball, Trav

2 & 2 - Brown, Swanny

3 & 3 - Both Harry

4 & 4 - Both Sidey

5 & 5 - Swanny and Pendles

Other combos ?

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

3 & 5 sidey
3 & 4 swan
4 & 2 Harry
5 pendles
2 etc

[thebaldfacts]

Interesting how one coach gives Pendles 5 and the other doesn't rank him in the top 5.

Goes to show we shouldn't be too critical of umps when they vote the brownlow. It is so hard.

Having said that I thought Sidey was BOG.

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

I believe the 5 votes to Pendles was a donkey vote. It has happened before in these votes, can't remember which coach did it though

[Pies4shaw]

Sidey played a fantastic game at the weekend, but what does Simon Chiarelli mean by referring to Sidey's "inquisitive on-field presence"? See: http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/20 ... ollingwood



I'm a little less in the dark about Pendles finding "solace amidst the chaos" - but only a little.

[Albert Parker]

Pendles didn't feature in many versions of the Gavin Brown medal votes from Nicksters this week.

Perhaps it was Bucks trying to keep him within range of the overall title

[thebaldfacts]

Given that Bucks drew special attention to Browns performance on Bucks Brief, I am assuming it was Bucks who gave him the 2 votes.

[Donny]

v. Swans.

10 Pendlebury (Coll)
6 Ball (Coll)
5 Swan (Coll)
3 Beams (Coll)
3 Macaffer (Coll)
3 Tippett (Syd)

Leaders.

90 Kieren Jack (Syd)
85 Gary Ablett (GC)
79 Scott Pendlebury
78 Joel Selwood (Geel)
76 Ryan Griffen (WB)
70 Daniel Hannebery (Syd)
65 Dane Swan
64 Patrick Dangerfield (Adel)
63 Nathan Fyfe (Frem)
60 Rory Sloane (Adel)

[Donny]

Pies.

79 Scott Pendlebury
65 Dane Swan
37 Steele Sidebottom
32 Travis Cloke
23 Harry O'Brien
20 Heath Shaw
17 Luke Ball
12 Sam Dwyer
10 Jamie Elliott
9 Paul Seedsman
7 Dayne Beams, Dale Thomas, Brent Macaffer
5 Nathan Brown
4 Jarryd Blair, Quinten Lynch
3 Ben Reid, Sinkers
2 Ben Kennedy, Marley Williams
1 Ben Hudson, Darren Jolly, Andrew Krakouer, Kyle Martin, Alan Toovey

[Tannin]

How about:

Pendlebury 5 5
Ball 4 2
Swan 4 1
Beams 3
Macaffer 3
Tippett 2 1

[thebaldfacts]

How about:

Pendlebury 5 5
Ball 4 2
Swan 4 1
Beams 3
Macaffer 3
Tippett 2 1

The first three are correct. The last 3 are interchangeable but Tippett getting votes from both coaches is possible.

[Hiss]

Here's mine in ranked order for the season thus far: (Rank order)

Collingwood: Jamie Elliott
Collingwood: Scott Pendelbury
Collingwood: Luke Ball
GCS: Gary Ablett
Hawthorn: Jarrod Ruffhead
Geelong: Pearce Akerman
Footscray: Arthur Gianserakusa
North Melbourne: Brent Harvey
Sydney: Adam Goodes

[Tannin]

How about:

Pendlebury 5 5
Ball 4 2
Swan 4 1
Beams 3
Macaffer 3
Tippett 2 1

The first three are correct. The last 3 are interchangeable but Tippett getting votes from both coaches is possible.

Yup. Impossible to tell. You can quite sensibly see the 2 & 1 going to any of the last three.