At his point in time Labour is slightly ahead in Caulfield. This is a huge shock and is on the same scale as Hawthorn. It's gone Labour, Libs and now too close to call since last week!
I still think the Libs will get in by further postal votes but to rid the Parliamant of Southwick would be doing a community service.
https://www.theage.com.au/politics/vict ... 50jdu.html
Vic State Election
Moderator: bbmods
-
watt price tully
- Posts: 20842
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2007 1:14 pm
So, the ABC has finally adjusted its predictions and has decided that the Greens are going to retain Melbourne and Prahran and win Brunswick.
Moreover, now that the dust has settled on the Northcote situation, it is plain that the ALP's hold on the seat is now marginal. The ALP held it on 6.04% margin after the 2014 State election (and a margin of about 4,700 votes), lost it at the 2017 byelection and now holds it on the two-party preferred vote by only 1.7% (a margin of under 400 votes) from the Greens.
Moreover, now that the dust has settled on the Northcote situation, it is plain that the ALP's hold on the seat is now marginal. The ALP held it on 6.04% margin after the 2014 State election (and a margin of about 4,700 votes), lost it at the 2017 byelection and now holds it on the two-party preferred vote by only 1.7% (a margin of under 400 votes) from the Greens.
-
Wokko
- Posts: 8764
- Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2005 12:04 pm
Liberals need to figure out if they're a party of inner city elite 'moderates' or try and change tack and bring in the working class "Howards Battlers" again who they've lost en masse in Victoria.
Conservative politics isn't the domain of rich douchebags from the inner suburbs anymore but the Libs haven't figured that one out yet.
Conservative politics isn't the domain of rich douchebags from the inner suburbs anymore but the Libs haven't figured that one out yet.
-
Jezza
- Posts: 29544
- Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 11:28 pm
- Location: Ponsford End
- Has liked: 271 times
- Been liked: 350 times
Exactly. The Liberals are splitting and need to make an important decision on what they ideologically stand for.Wokko wrote:Liberals need to figure out if they're a party of inner city elite 'moderates' or try and change tack and bring in the working class "Howards Battlers" again who they've lost en masse in Victoria.
Conservative politics isn't the domain of rich douchebags from the inner suburbs anymore but the Libs haven't figured that one out yet.
I don't think the "Labor-lites" and conservatives can peacefully co-exist with one another anymore.
| 1902 | 1903 | 1910 | 1917 | 1919 | 1927 | 1928 | 1929 | 1930 | 1935 | 1936 | 1953 | 1958 | 1990 | 2010 | 2023 | The "Labor-ites" you refer to are the old Liberal Party that many people used to vote for. There's no need to vote for the Duttzis when you can vote for the ALP and get, more or less, Liberal-Lite.Jezza wrote:Exactly. The Liberals are splitting and need to make an important decision on what they ideologically stand for.Wokko wrote:Liberals need to figure out if they're a party of inner city elite 'moderates' or try and change tack and bring in the working class "Howards Battlers" again who they've lost en masse in Victoria.
Conservative politics isn't the domain of rich douchebags from the inner suburbs anymore but the Libs haven't figured that one out yet.
I don't think the "Labor-lites" and conservatives can peacefully co-exist with one another anymore.
-
watt price tully
- Posts: 20842
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2007 1:14 pm
-
David
- Posts: 50683
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 4:04 pm
- Location: the edge of the deep green sea
- Has liked: 17 times
- Been liked: 83 times
The Greens have won in Prahran again, which means that, along with Brunswick (which was called for them on the weekend), they now have three lower-house seats (same as last term).
"Every time we witness an injustice and do not act, we train our character to be passive in its presence." – Julian Assange
-
Jezza
- Posts: 29544
- Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 11:28 pm
- Location: Ponsford End
- Has liked: 271 times
- Been liked: 350 times
According to ABC:
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY:
Labor = 54
Coalition = 25
Greens = 3
Independent = 2
Four seats are still in doubt.
Benambra (currently held by Liberal) = 89.6% counted
- Liberal = 20,817 (50.3%)
- Independent = 20,593 (49.7%)
Difference of 224 votes.
Hawthorn (currently held by Liberal) = 90.9% counted
- Labor = 19,717 (50.2%)
- Liberal = 19,544 (49.8%)
Difference of 173 votes.
Mildura (currently held by Nationals) = 88.3% counted
- Independent = 18,752 (50.3%)
- National = 18,512 (49.7%)
Difference of 240 votes
Ripon (currently held by Liberal) = 91.4% counted
- Liberal = 20,178 (50.1%)
- Labor = 20,099 (49.9%)
Difference of 79 votes
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (projection):
Labor = 19
Coalition = 10
Derryn Hinch's Justice Party = 3
Transport Matters Party = 2
Greens = 1
Shooters, Fishers and Farmers = 1
Liberal Democrats = 1
Animal Justice Party = 1
Sustainable Australia = 1
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY:
Labor = 54
Coalition = 25
Greens = 3
Independent = 2
Four seats are still in doubt.
Benambra (currently held by Liberal) = 89.6% counted
- Liberal = 20,817 (50.3%)
- Independent = 20,593 (49.7%)
Difference of 224 votes.
Hawthorn (currently held by Liberal) = 90.9% counted
- Labor = 19,717 (50.2%)
- Liberal = 19,544 (49.8%)
Difference of 173 votes.
Mildura (currently held by Nationals) = 88.3% counted
- Independent = 18,752 (50.3%)
- National = 18,512 (49.7%)
Difference of 240 votes
Ripon (currently held by Liberal) = 91.4% counted
- Liberal = 20,178 (50.1%)
- Labor = 20,099 (49.9%)
Difference of 79 votes
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (projection):
Labor = 19
Coalition = 10
Derryn Hinch's Justice Party = 3
Transport Matters Party = 2
Greens = 1
Shooters, Fishers and Farmers = 1
Liberal Democrats = 1
Animal Justice Party = 1
Sustainable Australia = 1
| 1902 | 1903 | 1910 | 1917 | 1919 | 1927 | 1928 | 1929 | 1930 | 1935 | 1936 | 1953 | 1958 | 1990 | 2010 | 2023 | Assuming that is right and giving Ripon to the Libs, the numbers would be ALP 55, LNP 27, Greens 3 and Independents 3.
The LNP will need to gain 18 seats at the 2022 election to govern without minor parties. There are other ways to cut the figures, of course, but the following looks to me to be a reasonable estimate of the present position.
Assuming they can recover all 3 seats held by independents (essentially as National Party seats), they will need on present percentages (which, of course, will change with a redistribution before the next election) to achieve a uniform (or equivalent) 7% swing across the board to take at least a further 14 seats directly from the ALP (it is almost inconceivable that they can take either of Brunswick or Melbourne without a coup), then take either Prahran from the Greens or Eltham from the ALP as well (both are on a 7.2% margin). The Nats 6 seats look safe (present margins are between 12.6% and 24%). On the other hand, the Libs hold 9 seats by 1.7% or less and, as things stand, none by more than 7.3%. By contrast, the ALP holds 40 seats by at least 8.5%.
Thus, although the Liberal vote probably bottomed-out at this election, they wouldn't want a further 2% slide - or they could easily be cut to just 12 seats in the Assembly from 2022.
The LNP will need to gain 18 seats at the 2022 election to govern without minor parties. There are other ways to cut the figures, of course, but the following looks to me to be a reasonable estimate of the present position.
Assuming they can recover all 3 seats held by independents (essentially as National Party seats), they will need on present percentages (which, of course, will change with a redistribution before the next election) to achieve a uniform (or equivalent) 7% swing across the board to take at least a further 14 seats directly from the ALP (it is almost inconceivable that they can take either of Brunswick or Melbourne without a coup), then take either Prahran from the Greens or Eltham from the ALP as well (both are on a 7.2% margin). The Nats 6 seats look safe (present margins are between 12.6% and 24%). On the other hand, the Libs hold 9 seats by 1.7% or less and, as things stand, none by more than 7.3%. By contrast, the ALP holds 40 seats by at least 8.5%.
Thus, although the Liberal vote probably bottomed-out at this election, they wouldn't want a further 2% slide - or they could easily be cut to just 12 seats in the Assembly from 2022.
-
stui magpie
- Posts: 54841
- Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 10:10 am
- Location: In flagrante delicto
- Has liked: 132 times
- Been liked: 166 times
^
It's interesting.
Victoria was always a traditional Liberal state until recently, while NSW was more Labor, which had an impact on industrial relations in the 2 states. That seems to have reversed in recent times.
In Vic, the libs will be pushing shit uphill. The old adage will run true, people don't vote in new governments they vote out bad ones. It's up to Labor and Dandrews to stay in.
It's interesting.
Victoria was always a traditional Liberal state until recently, while NSW was more Labor, which had an impact on industrial relations in the 2 states. That seems to have reversed in recent times.
In Vic, the libs will be pushing shit uphill. The old adage will run true, people don't vote in new governments they vote out bad ones. It's up to Labor and Dandrews to stay in.
Every dead body on Mt Everest was once a highly motivated person, so maybe just calm the **** down.
-
Culprit
- Posts: 17242
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2003 8:01 pm
- Location: Port Melbourne
- Has liked: 57 times
- Been liked: 68 times
Now former shadow attorney-general John Pesutto is looking for a new job. It's pure Karma. Greens winning Prahran, so it's never over till it's over.
ALP will have to sway say 3 voters in the upper house.
Where do they get the three votes required to pass legislation?
Derryen Linch, mostly vote Liberal
Liberal Democrats by name will vote Liberal
Transport Matters being Taxi Operators will definitely vote Liberal as I cannot see the ALP Government accepting their demands.
NRA, I would suggest would vote Liberal.
Greens will be an ally in most cases and that leaves Animal Justice Party and Sustainable Party and I would say that they are achievable.
Their may be some wheeling and dealing but it's not too bad.
In saying that I would suggest the Liberals will join the ALP in voting in amendments to the preference system to kill off the pop up parties.
ALP will have to sway say 3 voters in the upper house.
Where do they get the three votes required to pass legislation?
Derryen Linch, mostly vote Liberal
Liberal Democrats by name will vote Liberal
Transport Matters being Taxi Operators will definitely vote Liberal as I cannot see the ALP Government accepting their demands.
NRA, I would suggest would vote Liberal.
Greens will be an ally in most cases and that leaves Animal Justice Party and Sustainable Party and I would say that they are achievable.
Their may be some wheeling and dealing but it's not too bad.
In saying that I would suggest the Liberals will join the ALP in voting in amendments to the preference system to kill off the pop up parties.