This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
https://magpies.net/
As an aside, Snoop Dog highly values your bloke Karpany as highly skilled & talented player, great skill set & doing very well this year. The issue being he's slightly built despite playing in the SANFL.Rick wrote:Sounds like Aish might slide through to 6 and may be why we traded up. I'm hoping Nathan Freeman will be there at 10, strong and explosive.
Actually we've got a number of elite runners already but the problem is they're nearly all one-paced or plodders (ie: Sidebottom, Clarke, Lynch, Cloke etc) &/or poor users of the footy so I'd say what we actually need is elite runners who are quick, good decision makers, and can execute with precision. Not too much to ask forAN_Inkling wrote:If Aish is available we'd almost certainly take him ahead of those two. He's not a midget, 184cm is a decent size for a midfielder. Let's not take our aversion to smalls to ridiculous lengths. Would we pass on Cotchin? In reality the number of 188cm plus mids in the league is quite small, and the number of quality ones even smaller, this is not a need you draft for.
I'd also tend to preferring us to pick at least one taller mid, but it shouldn't prevent us from picking a better player. The midget talk is a little overblown anyway. In terms of mids we have Thomas and Kennedy. Blair is more a forward and possibly a fringe player now. We also have one of the few genuine 190cm mids in Pendles and Harry on a wing. Up forward we have Dwyer (fringe, and likely even depth player now) and Elliott along with Blair. As a Rookie we have Martin who may never get another game. That's the full midget list.
What we actually need is elilte runners. Not talls (and the two don't often go together). The risk with most of the taller types is that they are hybrid players, not specialists. Will they ever become elite in any one position? It's hard to tell. I wouldn't mind picking one of them, but at 6 I'd probably prefer a definite genuine midfielder.
At this stage it would seem the following are the most likely top 10 to join Boyd at pick 1.The Boy Who Cried Wolf wrote:I suspect it'll be Lennon @ 6 (he'll be the best available that's still there imho), but 10 is very hard to pick who will be left. If we take Lennon, most likely Kolodjashnij, Freeman and Taylor will all be gone by 10. Bontempelli could be interesting but he'll also most likely be gone too by then. I think we'll be left with a choice out of Crouch or Acres, although one of either Bontempelli or McCarthy should still be available.
, Kelly and Scharenberg.Good morning Mr Swoop 42. Lennon is my first priority then one of Scharenberg, Bontempelli, Kolodjashnij or Acres- McCarthy or Acres as a roughie...swoop42 wrote:At this stage it would seem the following are the most likely top 10 to join Boyd at pick 1.The Boy Who Cried Wolf wrote:I suspect it'll be Lennon @ 6 (he'll be the best available that's still there imho), but 10 is very hard to pick who will be left. If we take Lennon, most likely Kolodjashnij, Freeman and Taylor will all be gone by 10. Bontempelli could be interesting but he'll also most likely be gone too by then. I think we'll be left with a choice out of Crouch or Acres, although one of either Bontempelli or McCarthy should still be available.
In no particular order Aish, Freeman, Bontempelli, Lennon, Kolodjashnij, Billings, McDonald (Nth pick
I'd settle for any two of those.
Salem, Taylor, Crouch, McCarthy, Sheed and Acres would be next in line.
Dislike the bit where McCarthy is technically a poor kick and needs confidence like the bit about strong marking.watt price tully wrote:I'd like Scharenberg, Bontempelli, Lennon & Aish.
Cameron McCarthy is another one being touted highly - from WA.
http://boundforglorynews.com/2013-draft ... -mccarthy/
Above link has him at 195cm
While the AFL website has him at 193cm.
www.afl.com.au/news/2013-10-20/cameron-mccarthy
Thought he'd fit right inneil wrote:Dislike the bit where McCarthy is technically a poor kick and needs confidence like the bit about strong marking.watt price tully wrote:I'd like Scharenberg, Bontempelli, Lennon & Aish.
Cameron McCarthy is another one being touted highly - from WA.
http://boundforglorynews.com/2013-draft ... -mccarthy/
Above link has him at 195cm
While the AFL website has him at 193cm.
www.afl.com.au/news/2013-10-20/cameron-mccarthy
Sounds like Cloke mk2
Does your math holdup given North take McDonald at 8?The Boy Who Cried Wolf wrote:I suspect it'll be Lennon @ 6 (he'll be the best available that's still there imho), but 10 is very hard to pick who will be left. If we take Lennon, most likely Kolodjashnij, Freeman and Taylor will all be gone by 10. Bontempelli could be interesting but he'll also most likely be gone too by then. I think we'll be left with a choice out of Crouch or Acres, although one of either Bontempelli or McCarthy should still be available.
Do you think Aish will still be available at 10? He could be the Grundy of this draft and slide out. Apparently there might be ? Over his shoulder. I reckon we'll swoop on him at 6.MagpieBat wrote:Pick 6: Bontempelli
Pick 10: Aish