Post Match. Pies pipped in thriller. All comments, please.

[think positive]

What has happened to Jeremy Howe? I couldnt watch the last half. Is it a bad injury?

It looked it, his knee flew sideways

[masoncox]

Why all the love for Moore, sure he was great for the first 1.5 quarters then his disposal turned to crap and he cost us goals on multiple occasions?
Don't even get me started on Mayne, C. Brown, Maynard and Noble. All of these players owe Jez as he did his knee for nothing because of their ineptitude!

Half the team were crap.
Wills disappeared in the last half.
Must send him a magician package.

[Piesnchess]

I really think we lost that one ourselves, , rather than Giants beating us, we beat ourselves, shocking kicking for goal, and Maynards howler. Cancel out his clustercluck and we win, simple as that. But we really cant miss set shots like we did, its heartbreaking, deflates the whole team. bigtime. I look forward to playing these pricks on the G oneday soon, we can learn a lot from this loss.

[Dark Beanie]

No Howe and Roughhead won't go to Perth

Why no Roughead?

[Johnno75]

It’s quite laughable. 1st half our mids couldn’t get their hands on it. Then in the last when the ball was camped inside our forward 50 our forwards couldn’t get near it. Stevo did nothing after the first 20 mins. Elliot no impact. C Brown can’t be trusted from anything beyond 30. Need players that are clean at ground level in F50.

Then 3 brain farts cost us dearly in the 2nd half.

[VicParkTragic]

We will get them next time. We are sitting with a win / loss ratio of about 71%. We will get better. We have a lot of headspace for improvement.

[3rd degree]

What happened to Roughead?

Nothing ,old mate is just positive. Roughead mentioned his partner is not well.

[Haff]

Let DeGoey go and throw the kitchen sink at Cameron. Cox just isn’t up to it.

Bit harsh, first game back for many months, last august i think, i can cut him some slack, its Maynards brain fart that haunts me, that was just a shocker, plus our set shots for goal too.

Played rd 1 actually and was quite good. Came good tonight by the last, will be better for the run.

But given he is the only player on our list who can take a big mark up forward, he should be pretty safe. Often comes good in the last qtr of close games as players tire.

Sorry, Moore well ahead despite his horrid kick tonight which cost us a goal.
JDG just doesn’t do enough.
Maynard effort on Green was putrid. Cost us the game.

[Raw Hammer]

We handed them how many goals on a platter? Deplorable. Our set shot goal kicking is embarrassing. We have Cox and Mihocek. The rest have Cameron, Lynch, Kennedy, Riewoldt, et al. As horrible (HORRIBLE) as we played, we should have won. Figure that out. Anyway, with no reliable forward line and Howe done for the rest of the season, and maybe forever, this season is DONE.

We’ve won two games from four. Hardly premiership favourites.

[What'sinaname]

What happened to Roughead?

Wife has had a health scare and he wont go into a hub and leave her for this period.

[Johnno75]

No Howe and Roughhead won't go to Perth

Howe will have to go to Perth to collect his knee it went that far out of place.

[Magpietothemax]

Unfortunately we are starting to develop a reputation as flat track bullies.

Top sides lean on us and we fold like a deck of cards. Beat the Dogs in a game of round 1 covid-19 contact free basketball, escape with a draw against a top side after shitting the bed for 3 quarters, smack a mid-table saints side who have no idea what they're doing and now lose via horrible turnovers and goal kicking choking to a top side who applied 4 qtr pressure. These are gamestyle pathways that don't fill you with confidence that we will stand up at the pointy end of the year no matter how you want to explain it, sugar-coat it or excuse it.

We should have won that game against a contender but found a way to lose again. At no stage did I think we would, there is no 'eye of the tiger' so to speak of in this playing group.

A very frustrating football team we have here.

FFS so negative. We obviously didnt fold like a deck of cards, lost by 2 points. We drew against last year's Premiers... not just "some team". I am bitterly disappointed but this loss does not justify your rant. The main thing is Jeremy Howe. I hope to God this injury is not a severe one. If his ACL is done, then that is a massive blow for us.

[watt price tully]

Jeremy Howe, hope u recover soon.

Poor effort. Lost it between the ears. Self inflicted. The Brown brothers are just not good enough.

Poor match by Elliott, Stephenson for 3/4’rs, Cox but first game back, Sidebottom, Phillips for a lot of the match and those two misses FFS (let alone Stephenson’s miss)

Need Treloar back in a hurry.

Maynard was smashed tonight.

Buckley did not have a plan B.

Again poor conditions doesn’t help our cause.

Who will replace Howe?

[What'sinaname]

We handed them how many goals on a platter? Deplorable. Our set shot goal kicking is embarrassing. We have Cox and Mihocek. The rest have Cameron, Lynch, Kennedy, Riewoldt, et al. As horrible (HORRIBLE) as we played, we should have won. Figure that out. Anyway, with no reliable forward line and Howe done for the rest of the season, and maybe forever, this season is DONE.

We’ve won two games from four. Hardly premiership favourites.

We haven't been able to beat last year's grand finalists.

[Magpies035]

Same old story from Collingwood. So frustrating. Our small forwards struggled a little. So many inside 50’s but couldn’t score. I keep repeating the same thing. Why haven’t we recruited a key position Forward