Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

How many more flags have the saints won than us?

Doesn't Dawes fill the full forward hole that we have? From the little I've seen of Dawes, I think he could improve if we give him some game time.

ramjet21 wrote:he'll be kciking his usual 85 goals plus in the navy blue again next year unless the dogs come to their senses and make a straight swap for lake. until then, its just grandstanding by the blues - more carlton nonsense.

if it was legit, i would have him. and i would be prepared to offer daisy and/or dawes in the deal to get him.

at a point where i just want a flag - im seriously not bothered who is wearing one of the 22 black and white shirts when we hoist the cup

Its legit. Just read Fev's managers statement and the language the Blues senior people are using. He is gawn from the blues.

They'd be a laughing stock of the biggest proportions should he not be traded now. Be the decision right or wrong, they have to stick to their word or no-one will respect them (even their own list).

GET FEV AT ALL COSTS!!!!


ADD ANOTHER 10,000 TO OUR MEMBERSHIP IF WE LAND HIM!!!

Oh, and to those people who are talking about seeing a Premiership in 3-5 years, forget it!
The players have outwardly been stating there intention to win one NOW!
As if they'd aim for anything less next year?!?!
To recruit a Coleman Medallist will no doubt bring us a lot closer to Premiership in 2010 than a skinny 17-18 yr old. And there's no-one on our list capable of what Fevola can do.

We have just the environment to see Fevola make a serious change to himself (it's an opportunity for him to rectify his image and career remember) and help take us to a FLAG!

Go Fev!

I dont think it will.

My GF who isn't a die hard fan, but does enjoy the footy every now and then just sent me a message saying...

I hate Fev he is a dirty player on and off the field. He isn't the Collingwood way!

She has a membership, but more than likely wont get one if we get him.

So some will jump on but a lot with jump off if we trade a couple of young and up and coming stars for Fev.

RICHO1991 wrote:I was rapped when we got Woewodin.. imediently got a new jumper and put number 2 on it

Would have been about the same time I put Jason Cloke's number on my back because I thought he would rebound from missing the 02 GF.

Guess we both stuffed up there.

spamalot wrote:Doesn't Dawes fill the full forward hole that we have? From the little I've seen of Dawes, I think he could improve if we give him some game time.

Will Dawes go anywhere near winning a Coleman Medal next year? Ever?
He's a promising player for sure, but if I were to pick a Full Forward for a dreamteam, would you think I was crazy if I chose Dawes ahead of Fevola?

Or any other player in the AFL for that matter?

favourites 2008 wrote:I dont think it will.

My GF who isn't a die hard fan, but does enjoy the footy every now and then just sent me a message saying...

I hate Fev he is a dirty player on and off the field. He isn't the Collingwood way!

She has a membership, but more than likely wont get one if we get him.

So some will jump on but a lot with jump off if we trade a couple of young and up and coming stars for Fev.

off set by the many that jump on

On given up or gaining memberships due to players, why does it matter you support the club not insert said player dont you?

Fatui Attata wrote:The players have outwardly been stating there intention to win one NOW!
As if they'd aim for anything less next year?!?!

They would have received a serious reality check after the rear end sandpaper job that both St Kilda and Geelong gave them.

But if you don't accept this, here's a question for you: when was the last time Cloke dominated or was a match winner against a quality team..... say, in the last 2 years?

gee a dud doesnt win the copeland and cut him some slack maybe sit up the top of the southern stand and see how hard he works, and as a 22 year old the kid had his jaw broken in an off field incident which I think stuffed him mentally, he will be great in years to come mark my words[/quote]

favourites 2008 wrote:I dont think it will.

My GF who isn't a die hard fan, but does enjoy the footy every now and then just sent me a message saying...

I hate Fev he is a dirty player on and off the field. He isn't the Collingwood way!

She has a membership, but more than likely wont get one if we get him.

So some will jump on but a lot with jump off if we trade a couple of young and up and coming stars for Fev.

If your girlfriend is threatening to abandon her CFC membership, then don't forget, next week's trade week... there are some very talented 17-18 yr olds out there with a lot of upside.. nudge nudge. Maybe even offer her up to Carlton in the package deal to seal Fevola!

Everyone looks better in Back N White!

Pied Piper wrote:

frankiboy wrote:Fev = Premiership

I don't give a &^@$ about the bad press, maybe he knew the club was going nowhere and thought this was his only out . He could change his ways, not that I'd care anyway.

I think Carlton have finally decided Fev = No Premiership, franki. And I think they're right. Why would they shop him otherwise?

I reckon we all have some idea of how close Dids was to being on the market at the end of last year. Why? He is and was a brilliant player, but made the club (i.e. corporate organisation) look bad.

If we had put Didak up for trade, any club that overlooked him because of his off-field issues would have to be half a dozen sandwiches short of a picnic.

I doubt that we need to look much further than that. Would Fevola be on the trade table if he hadn't gotten drunk at a function and made a fool of himself? No.

Fevola is a gamble. On the one hand he can be a superb goal scorer. He kicked 85 goals this year and won the Coleman. On the other hand

1. He will be 29 in January and probably has a maximum of three years in him.

2. He has a drinking problem and a probably a personality problem as well.

3. He turns into a complete sook if his opponent gets on top of him.

4. He does not seem to listen to club officials and teammates.

If we take him we should take him as a gamble, which means we don't give away our future for him. Pick 14 and 30, Dawes, Reid, anyone really good under 24 should not be swapped for Fevola because that is our future.

If Carlton wants Cox and pick 48 for Fevola then that's a good deal for us and worth the risk. I doubt that Carlton would like that deal, but I am not sure that they will get any better anywhere else. Fevola is a good footballer but he is widely seen as damaged goods.

spoljar wrote:

Fatui Attata wrote:The players have outwardly been stating there intention to win one NOW!
As if they'd aim for anything less next year?!?!

They would have received a serious reality check after the rear end sandpaper job that both St Kilda and Geelong gave them.

^^^ Stating the bleeding obvious there.

My point was not about whether they fulfilled their intention or not. If it was, then I'd be a real boofhead wouldn't I? It was about whether or not we are only looking at youth.

Regardless of the outcome, they clearly want to win a flag.
IE recruit Fevola.
If they were rebuilding.... forget him...go strictly for youth.