Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

does anyone know the points of Ball, Jolly, Fraser in the nab challage games?
I know that Jolly and Ball did well against St kilda, but what has Fraser been like in the nab games, before I put them in my team, I would just won't to know who is worth the payment?

Well Jolly didnt play in the first regional game. They played this week against Richmond. I'll have the scored mid-week. I get them emailed to me in the champion data email. Only Dream Team scores but.


You would put Jolly in before Fraser because he has more hitouts to advantage. Plus may take more contested marks and way more durable.


But I'll get back to you with their scores when I receive the weekly email. As I said, it is only Dream Team but.

I've got Fraser in my Super coach team. One he's cheaper and two he's going to play around the ground and will pick up a lot of cheap possessions in a Dean Cox "link up" type role. Plus when he does ruck he'll most likely be doing against the opposition number two ruck and should clean.

Under 500 grand, you'd have to take Jolly.

Fraser was a bargain about two, three years ago, but I rekon he's too pricey this year.

OEP wrote:I've got Fraser in my Super coach team. One he's cheaper and two he's going to play around the ground and will pick up a lot of cheap possessions in a Dean Cox "link up" type role. Plus when he does ruck he'll most likely be doing against the opposition number two ruck and should clean.

up..

sorry I have a tendency to finish other peoples sentences

I would go Keefe or O'Shea




(only becuase I think were in the same league)

frasers mum sacked josh from her SC team, that should tell you something.

but what i meant was that what was their SC scores from the nab challenge games, to see which one is, the better opption for my team, if you can only get the dream team scores then thats ok they a only 10-15 points difference between the two

they are impossible to get. AFL don't release them. Champion data are the only place that have the stats...and they send out a weekly newsletter which you can sign up for on the champion data website.

But it is only Dream Team scores. But still gives you an indication.

The stats are only taken by the clubs and champion data. Not made public.

Ball would be the only one I would be getting out of those 3, but even then there are much better options around.

Guys like Wells and S Burg have history of scoring well in SC and would be a much better buy than Ball imo... even though they have had "poor" preseasons.

As for Jolly I can't imagine he will score as well for the pies as he has better back up and therefore TOG will be down.

Fraser is shot... look to Sandilands, Clarke or Tippet for some value.

I got Jolly in cos he previosly is a good scorer. I'm also intrested on how he preforms for us. SC is an indicator.

Thing is jolly is coming from a Swan game plan that has the most ball ups/boundary throw in in the comp. That means oohe gets to more contests. and gets more scores.

We don't have nearly as many ruck contests as teh Swans. Not sure he'll score as well as previously.

Fraser is a good scorer when he is fit and firing, Especially as a lone ruck. Byt neither on those look likely

I have Jolly and Nick Nat as my rucks. Skipper may be a good cheapy with Taylor going down.

I got Jolly in cos he previosly is a good scorer. I'm also intrested on how he preforms for us. SC is an indicator.

Thing is jolly is coming from a Swan game plan that has the most ball ups/boundary throw in in the comp. That means oohe gets to more contests. and gets more scores.

We don't have nearly as many ruck contests as teh Swans. Not sure he'll score as well as previously.

Fraser is a good scorer when he is fit and firing, Especially as a lone ruck. Byt neither on those look likely

I have Jolly and Nick Nat as my rucks. Skipper may be a good cheapy with Taylor going down.