Post Match. Pies beat Lions - All comments please

[Donny]

Collingwood 18.21.129
Brisbane 13.6.84

Goals: Elliott 4, Moore 3, Fas, Wells 2, Treloar, Adams, Sidey, Maynard, Dunn, Broomy, Smith 1.

Disposals: Sidey 34, Adams 33, Pendles 31, Treloar 30, Maynard, Smith 25, Crisp 22, Wells, Phillips 20, Grundy 19, Broomy, Fas, Howe, H-E 17, Shaz, Levi 16, De Goey, Dunn 15, Goldy, Blair, Elliott 14, Moore 13

DE%: Goldy 92.9, Howe 88.2, Shaz 87.5, De Goey 86.7, Maynard 84, Crisp 81.8, Wells 80, Grundy 78.9, Adams 78.8, Pendles 77.4, Treloar 73.7, Smith 72,

AF points: Sidey 129, Pendles 125, Treloar 109, Grundy 107, Smith 103, Elliott 102, Moore, Adams 97, Maynard 96.

Crowd: 32,750

Let's hear ya !!

[Jezza]

Take the four points and move on.

Happy with the way we finished the match.

[scoobydoo]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

[Dave The Man]

We Won but My God that was Very Unconvincing

[mgh3536]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

28 uncontested!!!
5 clangers!!!
64% disposal efficiency!!!

[Wokko]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

Efficiency: 64.7%
Clangers: 5

3 goals kicked off his turnovers

At least 4 "effective" possessions to a teammate under pressure resulting in turnovers.

Lots of dinky, nothing kicks

[schuey07]

The last term is basically irrelevant we will win by how much who knows but today there has been 4 players who should never wear our jersey again
Th coach & assistants should all be publicly put on notice by the club after today's effort
It's unbearable to watch this lot week in week out

You talk a lot of shit. These are the worst conditions to play in. You've probably never played AFL at any level. Keyboard warrior.

Mate take a long hard look at yourself before you go off calling names
I'm as entitled to an opinion as you whether you agree with it or not doesn't concern me
32 touches means nothing when you have 9 clangers resulting in 3-2 to them
He's had another dirty day and like any player paid the coin he gets from members money like mine should be called out on it
If you ever learn to read correctly I have bagged a few others today as well but none are on his coin or length of contract.
As for playing I haven't your right but I will bet penny to a million I've sat in more coaches boxes with ex afl coaches watching and learning about the game than you've had hot meals

All good and well being in a coaches box, but I have played and at decent levels as well, your skills decline when it's wet, the ball is heavy it's not easy. You have a hard on for bagging Sidebottom, that's seen in most of your posts. You get out when it's wet and muddy, put some boots on and see how many targets you hit.

[qldmagpie67]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

Actually 2 goals &
9 clangers
That's right over 25% of his touches were clangers/turnovers
How many meters gained today ???
That will tell you about his touches mate
Nothing positive comes from them
Like the 50 Mitchell got last week meant nothing when they are all sideways or backwards or clangers

[neil]

hated the third qtr cannot believe how baf the shots at goal were
Happy we won Elliot Moore Sidey Adams Dunn Pendles great
Not convinces about Smith Phillips is poor and Broomhead was underwhelming
Shaz had a good debut

[Haff]

Meh. Nothing win Really despite the Elliot and Moore positives.

[mosig]

Sounds like I did well to miss the 2nd half. Telstra's ability to make a solid mobile app seems to be matched only by our goal kicking.

[The Boy Who Cried Wolf]

Well that was convincing. Let the lid off!!

[scoobydoo]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

Efficiency: 64.7%
Clangers: 5

3 goals kicked off his turnovers

At least 4 "effective" possessions to a teammate under pressure resulting in turnovers.

Lots of dinky, nothing kicks

3 different radio stations gave him BOG
But what would they know, they only played the game

[qldmagpie67]

You talk a lot of shit. These are the worst conditions to play in. You've probably never played AFL at any level. Keyboard warrior.

Mate take a long hard look at yourself before you go off calling names
I'm as entitled to an opinion as you whether you agree with it or not doesn't concern me
32 touches means nothing when you have 9 clangers resulting in 3-2 to them
He's had another dirty day and like any player paid the coin he gets from members money like mine should be called out on it
If you ever learn to read correctly I have bagged a few others today as well but none are on his coin or length of contract.
As for playing I haven't your right but I will bet penny to a million I've sat in more coaches boxes with ex afl coaches watching and learning about the game than you've had hot meals

All good and well being in a coaches box, but I have played and at decent levels as well, your skills decline when it's wet, the ball is heavy it's not easy. You have a hard on for bagging Sidebottom, that's seen in most of your posts. You get out when it's wet and muddy, put some boots on and see how many targets you hit.

Mate fair enough and I do own up to bagging him and have done since 2014 when I believe the opposition coaches figured him out.
All the players play under the same conditions so that can't be used as a excuse he does the same dinky kicks and stupid handballs in the best conditions.
My thing is he's 170 odd games in and still makes the same errors weekly rookies get bagged for doing yet isn't held accountable plus he's a leader of this football club
He isn't top of my list of players I want gone Faz has that honour but he's on the list unless he loves up to his weekly pay packet and position in the team as a leader

[qldmagpie67]

Sidebottom
34 poss
8 marks
7 tackles
1 goal
Terrible game

Efficiency: 64.7%
Clangers: 5

3 goals kicked off his turnovers

At least 4 "effective" possessions to a teammate under pressure resulting in turnovers.

Lots of dinky, nothing kicks

3 different radio stations gave him BOG
But what would they know, they only played the game

All in Shepparton I'm guessing lol
So which ones gave him bog ??!