Mighty Magpie's Offseason Trade and List Management Blog

[ad4eva]

Id suggest we will look to rookie him. You need to be delisted first to do so.

When you think about it though, it doesn't come to as much of a shock as you would first think.

With his size and speed in the modern game, his roll has been reduced to a ruck/resting forward. Throw in the addition of Jordan Roughead and our stocks are quite high here. Grundy, Cox and Roughead all sit before McLarty as it stands right now.

I think we would be making a mistake to assume he is competing for a spot against Moore, Dunn, Goldsack and Scharenberg. Even Magden was called upon before McLarty.

He is more likely competing with Max Lynch and I'm not sure how comfortable the club will be with two rucks on the rookie list.

I don't mind the idea. Rucks take time and in reality, these guys wont be in the conversation for senior selection unless we are in dire straights with injury or form in some cases they can be promoted to the senior list anyway.

[3rd degree]

[BazBoy]

We all have our own opinions on players and IMO Magden does not appear to have footy smarts needed for top competitive competition

McLarty to be compared would need to have played or go on to play an AFL game or two

If he is cut adrift in luie of Magden then I consider that a poor decision

[Mr Miyagi]

Following players will be having a quiet beer tonight:

Jarryd Blair, Josh Daicos, Tyson Goldsack, Levi Greenwood, Kayle Kirby, Jack Madgen, Sam McLarty, Adam Oxley, Josh Smith.

I'm with Baz, I'm not sold on Madgen. Maybe give him another year in the Magoos, but he reminds me too much of Keeffe and a headless chook. I hope he proves me wrong.

[BazBoy]

By all means Jack will have more time —if at all give Sam simalar opportunity

[thesoretoothsayer]

[Mr Miyagi]

[Member 7167]

Oakley to be delisted and Smith may follow him based upon this article.\


https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/the-players-still-waiting-on-a-contract-ahead-of-first-list-deadline/news-story/7c7616e7d7f6f6dcf0a4e0786a82b016

[MatthewBoydFanClub]

[swoop42]

Adam Oxley was drafted in 2012.

Broomhead was selected in the same year as Grundy.

Let that sink in before deciding whether McLarty has been dudded.

[Pies4shaw]

It is beyond me why Oxley was recontracted last time.

[RudeBoy]

I'm rather surprised at McLarty's delisting, given how it often takes big blokes a few years to develop. However, the way the game is these days, he may have been judged as just being too slow, or not having the requisite footy smarts to play at the top level. Overall, you'd have to back the club's judgement, but this was one reasonably top pick of ours which, in hindsight, was wasted.

All the others were expected. I hope Broomhead can fight his way back, but given our midfield depth, it is going to take a massive improvement from him, even if he gets a rookie spot with us, for him to get on our senior list again.

[MightyMagpie]

And here we have it: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-30/suspended-murray-set-for-lifeline-as-pies-chop-five

I'll post an updated list shortly.

[MightyMagpie]

30-Oct-18
Games Age (Yrs) DOB Height (cm) Weight (kg) Contract

Primary List

1 Sidebottom 211 27.82 2-Jan-91 184 86 2021
2 Howe 162 28.34 29-Jun-90 190 88 2021
3 Treloar 139 25.64 9-Mar-93 182 86 2021
4 Langdon 80 24.39 9-Jun-94 190 83 2021
5 Thomas 67 27.08 1-Oct-91 178 79 2021
6 Stephenson 26 19.79 15-Jan-99 188 77 2021
7 Pendlebury 277 30.81 7-Jan-88 191 91 2020
8 Mayne 196 29.99 2-Nov-88 188 84 2020
9 D Beams 168 28.71 12-Feb-90 187 88 2020 Trade in
10 Roughead 138 27.99 3-Nov-90 200 100 2020 Trade in
11 Grundy 108 24.54 15-Apr-94 203 102 2020
12 Hoskin-Elliott 100 25.16 2-Sep-93 186 81 2020
13 Maynard 73 22.11 20-Sep-96 189 90 2020
14 De Goey 71 22.63 15-Mar-96 191 91 2020
15 Aish 68 22.98 8-Nov-95 183 80 2020
16 Moore 54 22.76 25-Jan-96 203 102 2020
17 Cox 44 27.63 14-Mar-91 211 108 2020
18 Scharenberg 31 23.12 18-Sep-95 191 90 2020
19 C Brown 13 20.51 27-Apr-98 178 77 2020
20 J Daicos 12 19.93 26-Nov-98 178 77 2020
21 Murphy 2 18.87 15-Dec-99 190 79 2020
22 T Brown 0 18.89 9-Dec-99 188 73 2020
23 Wells 257 33.74 3-Feb-85 181 84 2019
24 Varcoe 205 30.55 10-Apr-88 180 83 2019
25 Dunn 196 31.46 14-May-87 192 102 2019
26 Goldsack 165 31.44 22-May-87 193 93 2019
27 Reid 142 29.50 29-Apr-89 196 98 2019
28 Greenwood 135 29.69 19-Feb-89 181 87 2019
29 Adams 120 25.11 20-Sep-93 181 83 2019
30 Crisp 110 25.08 2-Oct-93 190 91 2019
31 Elliott 89 26.19 21-Aug-92 178 81 2019
32 Phillips 50 22.48 7-May-96 187 79 2019
33 Crocker 23 21.69 19-Feb-97 188 83 2019
34 Sier 12 20.88 12-Dec-97 191 88 2019
35 Wills 6 25.45 20-May-93 192 89 2019
36 Draft Selection 1
37 Draft Selection 2
38 Draft Selection 3
[39] Draft Selection 4
[40]

OUT
Fasolo 101 26.39 8-Jun-92 181 84 UFA to Carlton
Kirby 1 20.01 26-Oct-98 182 89 Delisted
Blair 157 28.54 14-Apr-90 174 80 UFA/Delisted
Smith 32 24.82 2-Jan-94 180 80 Delisted
McLarty 0 20.47 11-May-98 197 91 Delisted

Category A Rookies

1 Mihocek (Cat A R) 16 25.73 4-Feb-93 192 94 2020
2 Appleby (Cat A R) 9 19.77 21-Jan-99 187 82 2020
3 Broomhead 36 24.60 24-Mar-94 185 82 2019 Delisted and Offered Rookie
4 Lynch (Cat A R) 0 20.13 12-Sep-98 200 97 2019
[5] Murray 13 21.16 2-Sep-97 187 86 2019 Delisted and Offered Rookie
[6]

OUT
Oxley (Cat A R) 34 25.99 1-Nov-92 193 85 Delisted

NOTE: Primary List (38-40) plus Category A Rookies (4-6) cannot exceed 44 in total.

Category B Rookies

1 Anton Tohill (Cat B R) 0 18.88 14-Dec-99 199 86 2020
2 Mark Keane (Cat B R) 0 18.62 17-Mar-00 194 96
3 Madgen (Cat B R) 4 25.52 24-Apr-93 192 92 2019 *

[MightyMagpie]

If anyone has seen confirmation of Madgen's status in 2019, please post a link.