Ryan Griffin wants out from Dogs to GWS

Domesticated_Ape · Post by **Domesticated_Ape** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:45 pm

I wonder if this means GWS could be open to trading Treloar?

MJ23 · Post by **MJ23** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:46 pm

Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

This is actually really bad for us - means that if we do end up with pick 5 we have no hope of getting McCarthy or Wright in the draft.
All the mids after Brayshaw and Petrenco are relative to each other.

Lazza · Post by **Lazza** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:47 pm

MJ23 wrote:Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

This is actually really bad for us - means that if we do end up with pick 5 we have no hope of getting McCarthy or Wright in the draft.
All the mids after Brayshaw and Petrenco are relative to each other.

Very good point.

MagpieBat · Post by **MagpieBat** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:57 pm

jackcass wrote:How'd they get pick 7 of Carlton?

The speculation is (al beit, it's from Barrett, but let's go with it for a moment), that Carlton will trade pick 7 for Jaksch and Whiley from GWS, along with pick 19.

Gives GWS 4 & 7 for Griffen.

CarringbushCigar · Post by **CarringbushCigar** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:59 pm

MJ23 wrote:Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

Hell yeah, but our wise leader is reportedly on his way to Kuta Beach chasing Geelong rejects.

Damien · Post by **Damien** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:04 pm

Tippet was going to BrisVegas but only got as far as Sydney so Dane can too. Heater and Beams are both in the U.S at present if I'm not mistaken.

Get Heater in his ear, extolling the virtues of GWS. Give us Treloar and pick 4 (or even 7) for Beams - deal done.

CarringbushCigar · Post by **CarringbushCigar** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:08 pm

Lazza wrote:
CarringbushCigar wrote:thats either a pathetic cast with cheap bait or another pedantic statement
you're my first ignore ever
So you put up with other dicks and put one of the best posters here on ignore??
Yep, that sounds just about right from you......

who are u calling a dick?

Loungesuit u should do stand-up

I'm sure Bendigo could do with a laugh, or a good stoning

CarringbushCigar · Post by **CarringbushCigar** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:10 pm

Damien wrote:Tippet was going to BrisVegas but only got as far as Sydney so Dane can too. Heater and Beams are both in the U.S at present if I'm not mistaken.

Get Heater in his ear, extolling the virtues of GWS. Give us Treloar and pick 4 (or even 7) for Beams - deal done.

Burgo, lets not stuff this up.
Give em Beams and something and something to get Treloar.

Lets not harbour false hopes about Beams coming back - he is history!

Lazza · Post by **Lazza** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:15 pm

CarringbushCigar wrote:
Lazza wrote:
CarringbushCigar wrote:thats either a pathetic cast with cheap bait or another pedantic statement
you're my first ignore ever
So you put up with other dicks and put one of the best posters here on ignore??
Yep, that sounds just about right from you......
who are u calling a dick?

Loungesuit u should do stand-up

I'm sure Bendigo could do with a laugh, or a good stoning

You get the green, I'd love to get stoned dude.....

CarringbushCigar · Post by **CarringbushCigar** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:18 pm

Lazza wrote:
CarringbushCigar wrote:
Lazza wrote: So you put up with other dicks and put one of the best posters here on ignore??
Yep, that sounds just about right from you......
who are u calling a dick?

Loungesuit u should do stand-up

I'm sure Bendigo could do with a laugh, or a good stoning
You get the green, I'd love to get stoned dude.....

y'our'e on champ - ill look u up when they let me back into civilised society

Damien · Post by **Damien** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:20 pm

CarringbushCigar wrote:
Damien wrote:Tippet was going to BrisVegas but only got as far as Sydney so Dane can too. Heater and Beams are both in the U.S at present if I'm not mistaken.

Get Heater in his ear, extolling the virtues of GWS. Give us Treloar and pick 4 (or even 7) for Beams - deal done.
Burgo, lets not stuff this up.
Give em Beams and something and something to get Treloar.

Lets not harbour false hopes about Beams coming back - he is history!

If they're prepared to give up 4 & 7 for Griffin then Beams is worth Treloar and 7.

Give em Beams and 23 then for Treloar and 4.

That is feasible and is a win for both clubs and where they are on their journey right now.

Domesticated_Ape · Post by **Domesticated_Ape** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:21 pm

MJ23 wrote:Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

This is actually really bad for us - means that if we do end up with pick 5 we have no hope of getting McCarthy or Wright in the draft.
All the mids after Brayshaw and Petrenco are relative to each other.

I feel Treloar is about as good as Aish, so he'd only get half the Beams deal done for me.

Beams to Brisbane for Aish and pick 5
Picks 5 and 30 to GWS for Treloar.

GWS use pick 4 to get Griffen outright. Then picks 5 and 7 to trade up to pick 1 from St.Kilda if they're willing.

swoop42 · Post by **swoop42** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:35 pm

The dogs at this stage have stated that Griffen is a required player which is not surprising.

However we need to use this lull to begin serious talks with GWS over Beams and strike before the opportunity passes.

Beams needs to get it into his head that he might have to compromise on where he ends up if he's so desperate to leave the club and chase the money.

His best mate is at GWS and he's 50% closer to his dad and only an hours flight away.

Stuff Brisbane.

Just hope the club is being proactive on this issue now and exploring other alternatives.

MJ23 · Post by **MJ23** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:52 pm

Domesticated_Ape wrote:
MJ23 wrote:Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

This is actually really bad for us - means that if we do end up with pick 5 we have no hope of getting McCarthy or Wright in the draft.
All the mids after Brayshaw and Petrenco are relative to each other.
I feel Treloar is about as good as Aish, so he'd only get half the Beams deal done for me.

Beams to Brisbane for Aish and pick 5
Picks 5 and 30 to GWS for Treloar.

GWS use pick 4 to get Griffen outright. Then picks 5 and 7 to trade up to pick 1 from St.Kilda if they're willing.

Na, Treloar is one of the few players I'd be happy to straight swap for beams and think we got the better deal.
He is a gun.

Harvey · Post by **Harvey** » Thu Oct 09, 2014 4:05 pm

MJ23 wrote:
Domesticated_Ape wrote:
MJ23 wrote:Id rather Beams for Treloar straight swap.

This is actually really bad for us - means that if we do end up with pick 5 we have no hope of getting McCarthy or Wright in the draft.
All the mids after Brayshaw and Petrenco are relative to each other.
I feel Treloar is about as good as Aish, so he'd only get half the Beams deal done for me.

Beams to Brisbane for Aish and pick 5
Picks 5 and 30 to GWS for Treloar.

GWS use pick 4 to get Griffen outright. Then picks 5 and 7 to trade up to pick 1 from St.Kilda if they're willing.

Na, Treloar is one of the few players I'd be happy to straight swap for beams and think we got the better deal.
He is a gun.

Yea agree with a straight swap for Treloar. He's had a few years of development. Over that 50 games of experience and has shown three years of consistency as well as dramatic improvement every year. He is already a gun and would be very happy for a straight swap for Beams

This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.

Ryan Griffin wants out from Dogs to GWS