Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

RockabyDaisy wrote:if he wants to play for Collingwood we should make him state it publically like Akermanis did with the Dogs.
Other clubs had a chance Aker but because he only wanted to be with the dogs they left him.

That way every other club would risk picking a player who doesn't want to play for them.

100% Agree
this has to happens or might not get him.

dids_04 wrote: If carlton do pull the deal out of their arse, then maybe Collingwood should take note of what they do. In any case, I don't care what they do, the fact is they land the players they want. We don't. It's time for the men at the Lexus Centre to flex the muscle they claim they have......

Cousins is practically there for the taking. He is a superstar. It's a no-brainer. Then again, so was Tony Lockett......

Yep, if the Herald Sun says we are going after a player, everyone knows it must be true

I'll up your Lockett with a Buckley

dids_04 wrote:

Frank Stone wrote:

Fire Up wrote:

Frank Stone wrote:

Fire Up wrote:if cousins goes in the 1st draft in nov. we should get him with our 1st pick, it wil be a risk but 1 that could pay off. as we have a young side already. then we can get young players with our other picks.

but then on the other side of the coin the gold coast side will be coming in a few years so i guess topping up on young players could be a bonus as well

So with our first pick, you want us to take a 2 year player instead of a 10 year player?

Yeah right!!

dont know about you BUT i want pies to win a flag like within the next 3-5 years NOT wait another 32 years for another 1. look at the side we have atm we have the team to do it.

I know this
Cousins is not as valuable as pick 11 in this years draft

Once you have got that worked out, the rest is easy

we have not got enough kids with 'potential' for you?

what we lack is, funnily enough, experience, a match winner in the middle, a hard gut-runner and some pure star quality. Sound like Cousins to you?

Rewind to when he returned in 07. Tell me which kid we get at number 11 in the draft will perform like he did anytime in the next 4-5 yrs.....

and people wonder why we have won nothing for so long, with such a mentality, is it any wonder? If the club thinks along similar lines, we are stuffed.

Angry little pissant

Frank Stone wrote:

dids_04 wrote: If carlton do pull the deal out of their arse, then maybe Collingwood should take note of what they do. In any case, I don't care what they do, the fact is they land the players they want. We don't. It's time for the men at the Lexus Centre to flex the muscle they claim they have......

Cousins is practically there for the taking. He is a superstar. It's a no-brainer. Then again, so was Tony Lockett......

Yep, if the Herald Sun says we are going after a player, everyone knows it must be true

I'll up your Lockett with a Buckley

Yeah Buckley.....that's one. Well done. That surely cancels out the rest.

dids_04 wrote:

Frank Stone wrote:

dids_04 wrote: If carlton do pull the deal out of their arse, then maybe Collingwood should take note of what they do. In any case, I don't care what they do, the fact is they land the players they want. We don't. It's time for the men at the Lexus Centre to flex the muscle they claim they have......

Cousins is practically there for the taking. He is a superstar. It's a no-brainer. Then again, so was Tony Lockett......

Yep, if the Herald Sun says we are going after a player, everyone knows it must be true

I'll up your Lockett with a Buckley

Yeah Buckley.....that's one. Well done. That surely cancels out the rest.

Rocca
Clement
Medhurst
Holland


Want some more?

Wait ............

O'Bree
Licuria

Wood

Frank Stone wrote:

dids_04 wrote:

Frank Stone wrote:

Fire Up wrote:

Frank Stone wrote: So with our first pick, you want us to take a 2 year player instead of a 10 year player?

Yeah right!!

dont know about you BUT i want pies to win a flag like within the next 3-5 years NOT wait another 32 years for another 1. look at the side we have atm we have the team to do it.

I know this
Cousins is not as valuable as pick 11 in this years draft

Once you have got that worked out, the rest is easy

we have not got enough kids with 'potential' for you?

what we lack is, funnily enough, experience, a match winner in the middle, a hard gut-runner and some pure star quality. Sound like Cousins to you?

Rewind to when he returned in 07. Tell me which kid we get at number 11 in the draft will perform like he did anytime in the next 4-5 yrs.....

and people wonder why we have won nothing for so long, with such a mentality, is it any wonder? If the club thinks along similar lines, we are stuffed.

Angry little pissant

With the amount of Pies supporters that accept mediocrity, what do you expect?

Oh, of course, we have the kids. It's all good, you have assured me. We clearly don't need anything else.

Just don't bang on that we are the biggest and best club when we have won **** all recently and regularly do very little to change that. (apart from drafting 'potential')..... I suppose you think Carlton recruiting Judd was a mistake too?

You better hope they don't win a flag before us. Of course though, you will re-assure me that we have the kids with 'potential' still....

waste of time you are.

why are we so obsessed with landing a big name? let's create and/or develop our own ...

pendlebury
cloke
thomas
didak
anthony
brown
dawes
...

And a toe rag to boot

Pied Piper wrote:Lots of assumptions going on here.

People are assuming (a) that Ben Cousins is over his substance abuse issues; (b) that he can satisfy the AFL and interested clubs of the same; (c) that he will be able to resume at the same high level of performance after a year out of the game when he is already past 30; (d) that he could give anything up to four years' more service at the same level, which is statistically almost impossible; (e) that he is what our club most requires in the midfield, when in fact he is an elite outside endurance runner, not a clearance player; (f) that he is the difference between a top eight finish and a premiership.

I'm not saying a player of Ben Cousins' calibre wouldn't make a positive difference to the club, but once again:

EE'S NOT THE MESSIAH
EE'S A VERY NAUGHTY BOY!

This is the most sensible comment on this thread. If we were only one player short of the Premiership then Cousins might be worth using a high pick for, but we are at least three players short (four, if Burns retires) As Pied Piper says we need a clearance player. We need another Ruckman, because much as I love Bear's courage and committment he is not a top AFL ruckman, Wood might be, but his form dropped off alarmingly late in the season and I think we need three top ruckman to be safe.

Most of all, we need a full back capable of stopping big fast forwards, specifically we need a forward capable of beating Fev and at least breaking even with Buddy. Judd was not the reason the Scum beat us twice this year, Fevola was. Brown will one day be capable of beating Fevola or Franklin but he isn't yet and if people think that we are close to a flag next year then we should trade for Rutten. (or Glass, but we wouldn't get him)

Brereton
Osborne
Healy
Molloy
Brad Hardie

a few big stars there .

Anyway, the way it works now is you need to be near the bottom or give up just as much as you receive to get good players from other clubs. No point in whining over not having received a full team of other teams' players over the last decade.

Didn't we recruit a brownlow medallist too once?

yep i always bring that up whenever someone says a big name will solve our problems

AN_Inkling wrote:Brereton
Osborne
Healy
Molloy
Brad Hardie

a few big stars there .

Anyway, the way it works now is you need to be near the bottom or give up just as much as you receive to get good players from other clubs. No point in whining over not having received a full team of other teams' players over the last decade.

So is it about recruiting players or recruiting player YOU want?

Frank Stone wrote:

dids_04 wrote:

Frank Stone wrote:

dids_04 wrote: If carlton do pull the deal out of their arse, then maybe Collingwood should take note of what they do. In any case, I don't care what they do, the fact is they land the players they want. We don't. It's time for the men at the Lexus Centre to flex the muscle they claim they have......

Cousins is practically there for the taking. He is a superstar. It's a no-brainer. Then again, so was Tony Lockett......

Yep, if the Herald Sun says we are going after a player, everyone knows it must be true

I'll up your Lockett with a Buckley

Yeah Buckley.....that's one. Well done. That surely cancels out the rest.

Rocca
Clement
Medhurst
Holland


Want some more?

Wait ............

O'Bree
Licuria

Out of all them, one star player (Clement), one very good player (Licuria), one good player (Rocca). Medhurst too I suppose.....

Now compare to the ones we have missed out on. I'm not even going to bother listing them, speaks for itself and makes that list look rather lame.